I think Valkyrie Profile 2 handled it best because there was no power difference (usually) to the various einherjar. They lock some of the most powerful things in the game behind the gacha and that's just not good to me. Having a bunch of different characters is one thing, but tangible power is held behind that barrier and I see it as a terrible concept as a result.
I pop a bunch of cores too, and while you may say it's obsessive to min/max or whatever there are several blades that are definitely more powerful and combined with the need for a separate hard to get item to transfer blades and possibly getting the wrong blades on the wrong drivers there's several reasons why it is as hated as it is, and as much as I absolutely love the game will not defend.
To know you could get a gimped Nia or useless builds on Morag and then they go and do what they do with Rex later in the story really screws over that concept entirely.
I definitely farmed for cores myself and NG+ and the season pass free items helped, but let's not pretend like the system is anywhere close to well done.
I mean, I'm not trying to pretend the system is well done, just saying it didn't really bother me. The power gap between most blades isn't massive, and not big enough to stop you from finishing the game anyway. A lot of high end common blades - particularly ones with orb master - are more useful than a lot of rare blades too. Plus, a lot of the top tier blades are either obtained through the story or via quests.
You get Pyra, Mythra, Roc, Nia, Dromarch, Brighid, Aegaeon, Poppi, Poppi QT, Pandoria and Wulfric throughout the story. While you can get the likes of Poppi QT Pi (the most powerful blade in the game), Theory, Praxis, Sheba, Herald and Kasandra via quests you find in the world. Then of course you've got the three pity blades you will definitely get - and let's be honest, you're likely to get more over the course of the game.
No one will not be able to beat the game because of the gacha - you're handed too much on a plate. I do agree with you about overdrives however and I will say it's frustrating to have the most optimised builds locked behind luck. I don't think we're disagreeing with each other, just coming at the issue with different perspectives. :)
I'm saying I have 3 rare blades I need left out of all of them *whoosh*
Woops!
The pity system only works for certain blades (That are decided at the beginning of the game, when you save the game for the first time), one can go through 300 cores and never see KOS-MOS.
See above - misread the post. I think the game should eventually just give you everyone after a certain amount of pulls. It's a shame the pity system only extends to three blades.