• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Favourite Three Houses House Leader

  • Edelgard

    Votes: 393 52.1%
  • Dimitri

    Votes: 124 16.4%
  • Claude

    Votes: 237 31.4%

  • Total voters
    754

Z-Beat

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
31,833
Edelgard the worst. Claude the best though Blue Lions best route.
Dimitri has the best arc going from least interesting to most interesting to somewhere in the middle, Claude is the most likable of the 3. I actually prefer the final section of Golden Deer because it feels more conclusive on a story-scale but end of Blue Lions was cool too
 

effingvic

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,145
Dimitri has the best arc going from least interesting to most interesting to somewhere in the middle, Claude is the most likable of the 3. I actually prefer the final section of Golden Deer because it feels more conclusive on a story-scale but end of Blue Lions was cool too

I loved them both, but I was surprised at how much I liked Blue Lions due to Dimitri's depth and the personal nature of that route. Golden Deer was just fun from beginning to end and felt like a classic save-the-world JRPG that delivered on some truly hype moments.
 

Metroidvania

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,768
Slithers are the worst part of the game

The shame of it all is that they could be compelling, either/both through them being another 'gray' villain (the only evidence here is through the one book in the abyss via the DLC, and even that's likely skewed as all get out, given what we know of Sothis, and what we see of their actions before and during the game), and/or 'needing' Edelgard in order to further their goals, because they've been so weakened by inbreeding/no sunlight/etc, so they're reduced to this shadowy force because it's all they can do.

Instead they ramp up from 'shady force aligned with Edelgard' at the start of the story to 'throwing around ICBMs, body snatching/cloning, and resurrection, not to mention a secret high-tech underground base' by VW's end.

Like....body snatching alone could have made them secretly the puppetmasters behind each of the thrones - why limit yourself to Arundel, when you could just use his closeness to Ionius to take him on a trip, bring him to Faerghus' 'best doctor', then just replace him.

IIRC the in-game explanation is that this takes a bunch of time, but even so.

Edeldard simps need help.

The 'did nothing wrong' crowd is likely being somewhat hyperbolic given the supreme pushback the edelgard haters throw out incessantly, but I don't think many of Edelgard fans are truly, honestly thinking she's 100% blameless, or completely and utterly in the right.
 

Hailinel

Shamed a mod for a tag
Member
Oct 27, 2017
35,527
The 'did nothing wrong' crowd is likely being somewhat hyperbolic given the supreme pushback the edelgard haters throw out incessantly, but I don't think many of Edelgard fans are truly, honestly thinking she's 100% blameless, or completely and utterly in the right.
I'd hesitate to agree only because it feels like that crowd has been there since Day 1 and has led to some truly embarrassing moments on Era.
 

Hambulance

Member
Oct 30, 2017
1,617
Dimitri has the best glowup & personal route

Edelgard 2nd
I like her design(s) and she was ridiculously OP ingame, she never skipped axe day.

Claude last, gameplay was good, I mean BOW LORD!
Never really felt his character tho, we were told he's a master schemer but never saw any of that shit.
 
Oct 30, 2017
250
I'm a fan of Claude. He's a sneaky guy, but I do believe his cause and what he wants to accomplish are the overall best things that could happen to Fodlan.

Edelgard may have noble ideals, but when your means to accomplishing everything you want to do is murder, it's kinda hard to be the good guy. The answer to all her problems is to murder it away.

Dimitri...exists. Probably would have been a lot nicer guy if Edelgard wasn't around trying to murder everything.
 

BaconHat

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,097
I'd hesitate to agree only because it feels like that crowd has been there since Day 1 and has led to some truly embarrassing moments on Era.
At least it's not as bad as the "griffith did nothing wrong" crowd?
But yeah, trying to whitewash some of the characters actions makes me uneasy when reading posts sometimes.
 

Aaronrules380

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
22,427
Claude's easily the worst. He's a likeable character, but given that his entire motivation and character largely hinges around a region we never get to actually see ourselves and he honestly ends up feeling like he's only in this story for the ride because he's not actually that invested in Fodlan even in his own arc, which is exemplfied by the fact in literally any arc where he lives he fucks back off to Almyra the moment he feels he can leave the situation there to someone else. He'd be way better in a different game if I'm being honest
 

Morlas

Looking for a better cartoon show.
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
72,737
Why even have these threads when Best House and Best Lord always win?
 

Common Knowledge

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,236
As an overall character? Edelgard, she's a greatly written tragic villain. As, like, who I think is the best person and who I would want as my house leader? Claude.
 

Nimbat1003

Member
Nov 14, 2021
1,360
Love edelgard but I also played her route first which I think is a big part she kinda goes full final season daenerys in other routes though.
 

DeoGame

Member
Dec 11, 2018
5,077
Claude is a sweetie. Dimitri has some issues but is genuinely a good guy.

I don't like Edelgard. Which is odd. I love her character design, I love Platt's performance, I like the Black Eagles, but I just cannot get behind her motivations. They come across as short-sighted at best and masochistic at worst.
 

My Tulpa

alt account
Banned
Sep 19, 2021
1,132
Edelgard is one of the most interesting characters in the entire series, and maybe one of the most interesting JRPG protagonists ever, so definitely her.

It's so bizarre to me that she is so villainized as genocidal or fascist when she's the only one willing to actively fight back against the systemic abuse of Fodlan and the church to stop the theocratical authoritarian regime of the church and the blood cultism, feudalism, and genealogical tyranny of the continent across all its different countries.

Preach
 

Sadnarav

Member
Nov 6, 2019
858
Imagine not liking the one leader willing to attack and dethrone God, destroy the systematic abuse of nobility and the church even knowing she would be hated for doing the right thing?

I can only see Dimitri as a Church Cop and Claude as a coward
 

Leafshield

Member
Nov 22, 2019
2,934
Rhea's regime over the previous thousand years was responsible for keeping the continent in a feudal, medieval state, at each other's throats, under the heel of her theocracy. I was totally on board with anyone breaking the crest system, the power of the church and hers in particular. I don't see how allowing such theocratic tyranny to continue to avoid open warfare is fine just because it's the status quo. However, it's a shame that the only person willing to step up and do it was Edelgard. Sure, the *end results* of the other campaigns lead to Rhea backing off, but she's been a murderous tyrant for 30+ generations. I don't see why she gets to walk away with a 'alright I'll stop oppressing your entire continent' after all that she's done to the entire population of Fodlan for so long. That all powers are equally strong, leading to mass warfare, is down to Rhea keeping them all at that state of constant readiness for war- it was her way of making sure none of them ever gathered enough support to challenge her theocracy blocking all technological and social progress.

Still, Edelgard, looking for any advantage she can get to break the stalemate enacted by Rhea, chooses awful, murderous methods and allies. It's only in her own route that she comes across as more sympathetic and her early choices become even slightly *understandable* even against the tyranny of a dragon-god that can destroy cities, once you realise what's been done to her as a kid under the crest system and the lack of support even from her own empire, even if it isn't justifiable. She's still one of the more interesting FE leads for it though, rather than the usual generic teenage rookie heroes that engage in mass continent-wide medieval warfare against terrible odds and win through, getting everything right, every time without ever making terrible choices.

These discussions often revolve around the house leads, but what I thought was the strength of TH was the linked backgrounds of all 30+ characters across Fodlan's society, they are one of the strongest sets of backgrounds they've had. I loved reading about all of them and putting the links together.
 
Last edited:

Zyrox

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,618
Edelgard, to me, was the most interesting of the three and I liked her routes' resolution the most.
 

NioA

Member
Dec 16, 2019
3,627
I voted Dimitri but they're all pretty close.
Edelgard does a wonderful job as a villain, Dimitri has the most evident and clear growth out of all three (everything that has to do with his delusional prince phase is wonderful and a trope that FE never explored much) and Claude was the least "lordly" out of all the FE protagonist, which made him really unconventional as a characters. I just feel he needed more space out of all the characters, even a single chapter that deal with his role as leader in that other country would have done wonders. Too bad his beard is ridicolous lol
 

Uncle at Nintendo

â–˛ Legend â–˛
Member
Jan 3, 2018
8,577
Claude has the best route. Dimitri is the best character and has god tier battle animations post timeskip. Edelgard is just trash. Worst in battle, worst route, worst personality etc.
 

BaconHat

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,097
Reminder that "I like this character" doesn't mean "I identify with them 100% ideologically".
It also does not mean that you have to whitewash their actions when describing them. I mean, i agree with you, but there's little way that a sentence with 'imagine not liking that char' can be interpreted.
 
Oct 25, 2017
26,560
You know people talk about the strength of the Lord characters, but for my money, I'd argue Sylvain was the best unit in battle. And he's literally free if you play as female Byleth.
 

NoalleGospell

Member
Dec 3, 2018
1,748
Puerto Rico
Claude for me. Edelgard is a great villain with a complex morality but I will never understand the stanning she gets. (Also people disliking Edelgard doesn't mean they agree with Rhea too)
 

Morlas

Looking for a better cartoon show.
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
72,737
Claude has the best route. Dimitri is the best character and has god tier battle animations post timeskip. Edelgard is just trash. Worst in battle, worst route, worst personality etc.
lol worst in battle is just blatantly wrong, in fact from what I've seen most players think she might be the best unit in the entire game
 

Morlas

Looking for a better cartoon show.
Moderator
Oct 25, 2017
72,737
You know people talk about the strength of the Lord characters, but for my money, I'd argue Sylvain was the best unit in battle. And he's literally free if you play as female Byleth.
If we talk about best non-lord units my money goes on Lysithea tbh
 

Quinton

Specialist at TheGamer / Reviewer at RPG Site
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,252
Midgar, With Love
Paradoxically enough, Edelgard > Dimitri > Claude for character preference, but Claude > Dimitri > Edelgard for story routes.
 

Spinosaurus

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,980
Claude's a good boy and I will never forgive the game for doing him so dirty. His dilemma and motivations are far more interesting to me than the other two and I wish his route actually focused on that instead of just getting involved with white people bullshit.
 

Cruxist

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
3,812
It's Edelgard. Revolutions aren't bloodless, and history shows even the most virtuous goals require compromise with "evil" forces you may not agree with. Edelgard's path showcases this incredibly well. It's clear that there should've been a few more missions there, but honestly I was happy with the story I got.
 
The shame of it all is that they could be compelling, either/both through them being another 'gray' villain (the only evidence here is through the one book in the abyss via the DLC, and even that's likely skewed as all get out, given what we know of Sothis, and what we see of their actions before and during the game), and/or 'needing' Edelgard in order to further their goals, because they've been so weakened by inbreeding/no sunlight/etc, so they're reduced to this shadowy force because it's all they can do.

Instead they ramp up from 'shady force aligned with Edelgard' at the start of the story to 'throwing around ICBMs, body snatching/cloning, and resurrection, not to mention a secret high-tech underground base' by VW's end.

Like....body snatching alone could have made them secretly the puppet masters behind each of the thrones - why limit yourself to Arundel, when you could just use his closeness to Ionius to take him on a trip, bring him to Faerghus' 'best doctor', then just replace him.

IIRC the in-game explanation is that this takes a bunch of time, but even so.
Slithers as a concept do work on paper, a secret society that has just like the World Rhea helped make exploit and use this system for there own benefit and are connected to some of the most current tragedies in the country.

Issue is most of the good stuff with Slither is in the backstory current story there isn't much too them and honestly in two of the paths that Slither should have more of a Presences they just aren't much of a factor.

Edelagrd takes care of her Uncle and Slithers after the game, Edelagrd was much more focused on destroying the current system of Nobility and power propped up by the Church and Rhea so I can get skipping over them there.

In her Path, Edelgard never really considered them allies just means to an end and soon as they outlive there usefulness Hubert takes them down.

Dimitri path is more about his own past and personal trauma and his relationship with Edelgard more so then with Slither who are the ones responsible for his Kingdoms woes, Duscar and his family issues.

They never a focal point and in Blue Lions you can kill Slithers leader but its not even a blip on the radar.

In the end Slither is better executted in the past then there handling in the current storylines as I just don't like how its handled in the Church route (the worst one) or Golden Deer.
 

Metroidvania

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,768
Edelagrd takes care of her Uncle and Slithers after the game, Edelagrd was much more focused on destroying the current system of Nobility and power propped up by the Church and Rhea so I can get skipping over them there.

Eh...Edelgard doesn't 'need' to take care of the Slitherers on-screen personally, so much as getting a chance to blow out Nemesis would do wonders to assuage her route for the various naysayers (not to mention making her route equally long with the other routes, rather than abruptly ending with Arundel previously having menaced her and Byleth shortly before the last chapter)

Which, ties back to the lack of 'compelling' rationale (at least for some) for choosing Edelgard, and a marked lack of sincere introspection on the route itself, outside of Edelgard's personal support chain, +/- a few others.

Not spilling the beans on Thales and co. being the one to destroy the castle city even to the rest of the strike force is admittedly a pretty sus move no matter how you slice it.
 

MrWindUpBird

Banned
Oct 28, 2017
3,686
Edelgard simps are up there with Emet-Selch fans as getting major side-eye for all the dumb "she did nothing wrong!" posts that are genuine feelings that people try to pass off as "joking."

Shits creepy as fuck.
 

McNum

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 26, 2017
5,184
Denmark
They never a focal point and in Blue Lions you can kill Slithers leader but its not even a blip on the radar.
I love this bit of unintentional comedy on the Blue Lions route.

Dimitri is laser-focused on getting revenge for the Duscur Tragedy against Edelgard, who actually has nothing to do with it as she was nine and with Slither-inflicted problems of her own at the time, that he completely misses that he DOES get his revenge. As speedbumps along the way. He basically takes out the entire Slithers' leadership, but since they were all in disguise, he never knows.

Dimitri is the king of accidentally breaking the right thing.
 

IzzyRX

Avenger
Oct 28, 2017
5,814
As someone who still have to play it, I like Claude's design the best but everyone and their mother said I shouldn't start with Golden Deers for my first run.
 

Rutger

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,228
Claude's a good boy and I will never forgive the game for doing him so dirty. His dilemma and motivations are far more interesting to me than the other two and I wish his route actually focused on that instead of just getting involved with white people bullshit.
The game would have really benefitted from mixing up what starts the war in each route. Claude establishes that his own goals were to to obtain the sword of the creator's power and start his own conquest, but Edelgard makes the first move and he ends up feeling like he doesn't have much of a place.
 

Tochtli79

Member
Jun 27, 2019
5,777
Mexico City
Good to see the Edelgard haters are still just a very loud minority. Toxic as always of course. Always the same cries of "she did fascism" and/or "because she's a woman she must be a waifu".

She is my top pick, then probably Dimitri, then Claude just because he feels like the least involved in the story.