My initial impressions were SUPER rough.
Within 15 seconds of starting to make my first ever character, the camera shifted BEHIND my character. I was literally cycling through the faces and it just shifted behind randomly. I had to ALT+F4 and start again. Here's a shot of that from a video I recorded:
Second attempt: I made my character as I wanted. Finally! I even took a photomode photo of him! I got to walk around for about 15 seconds in that room you spawn in. I hit E to play the guitar and the game crashed. I was livid.
I started the game for a THIRD time. It probably saved my character, right? Must've since it would be stupid not to save it or sync up right after someone made their character right?
Nope. It didn't save my created character before it had crashed.
I had to redo it all over again. Luckily it didn't crash again and I was able to do a little bit of the initial quest stuff.
The bloom/god rays feels excessively intense at some points. I ran into a visual bug that I saw before in other games like Fallout 4, Mafia 3, and even State of Decay 2. It's not a constant bug, but it shows up under certain lighting conditions.
To note, this is what my character "normally" looks like:
I at least know now that borderless windowed is broken, so I won't comment on the super weird framerates I was seeing yet.
Once I actually got going though, it seemed to be pretty good. I'm still obviously super early on in the game, but I can see myself playing this every so often with like a stream or whatever on the other monitor.
But please please please Bethesda: Get a new engine already? You can put as many coats of paint on Gamebryo as you want, but at the end of the day it's still fucking Gamebryo. It's still an engine that has its roots going back to the late 90s. Also, I definitely understand that it's not
just the engine that is a problem but a lot of factors. But like... c'mon.