He is, yeah. You can always come back later. All evergaol bosses have been easy for me except this one. (Yes even (LATE GAME evergaol) Alecto!)
Yeah I'd happily take a half/quarter/third of lifesteal compared to what we have now. One single hit on my shield regains 2 of my hits of damage, let alone an entire flurry.
I always dodge her bigger attacks like the long charging thrust, the jumping sweeps etc anyway, but when she does that *glint* 1-2-3 combo, it comes out SO FAST that I am not able to dodge it, or not all 3 anyway, and trying to mix block and dodge here usually just fucks me over anyway, and boom she just undid all of my previous carefully timed hits.
Sometimes she will SPAM this combo, too. One time I just had to cry/laugh, I had taken off maybe 25-30% of her health, but she just went that *glint* 1-2-3 fucking THREE TIMES IN A ROW, without even a single other attack or a pause in-between. Even if I blocked some and dodged some, she was back at full health. Then, as I stared in disbelief, she did the omnislash thing and of course killed me, and this just killed any desire for me to ever fight her again. 😢
This was the Doom Eternal Ancient Gods DLC all over again, except even worse. Another balancing solution could be to cap her regained HP somehow, either by tiering her HP bar (I don't think From ever did that though) so she can't recover fully if you already damaged her a bit, or making it like Bloodborne style regain (she can only regain recently lost health), or... something.
Speaking of Bloodborne, I guess I'll probably Bloodborne this fight and try again with Quickstep or something, because I can't ever see myself winning with a sword and board style. Meh...
Isn't it obvious? You cannot play sword and board AT ALL on this fight, because she regains as much health on a blocked attack as she does on attacks that actually hit you. At best you might choose to block the very occasional hit, but you have to otherwise abandon your entire playstyle otherwise you will never out-damage her HP regain. You have to Bloodborne this fight no matter what, except Bloodborne gave you a FAR more generous dodge and parry, and enemies were never this aggressive in their flurries or as fast in their windup, not even Lady Maria or the Orphan.
I don't use ashes, but some people have vouched for Tiche.
Going to disagree. The shield allows for guard counters. Which is great at stomping through her poise, which means critical which often damages more than she healed. I don't always shield, but shield into guard counter a few of her moves works really well. Shield is great against her.
But to each their own. I think she is completely fun and fair as a strength sword and board player.