• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Oct 25, 2017
56,640
Ef4XrbHWsAACbnv.jpg
 

Skeeter49

I wish Jim Ryan would eat me
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,295
Tracksuit Gohan actually stomps Future Gohan with ease. Future Gohan was to be frank a weakling.

Dragon Ball fans have a bad habit of thinking 'cool = strong'. Which is why people keep underplaying the U6 Saiyans.
Yeah, at best the fight lasts a little longer than it would have lasted if tracksuit Gohan was back to his training self/ the Gohan in the exhibition tournament, which would easily wipe the floor with Future Gohan in one hit.
 

Kagari

潜在能力解放
Member
Oct 24, 2017
4,478
Yeah, at best the fight lasts a little longer than it would have lasted if tracksuit Gohan was back to his training self/ the Gohan in the exhibition tournament, which would easily wipe the floor with Future Gohan in one hit.
Nope, future Gohan is really that weak. He would still go down in one hit. Remember that in the movie Gohan took out a guy who was giving Piccolo trouble in one hit, and Piccolo is far stronger than the Androids were. Future Gohan couldn't beat the Androids.

You have to remember that peace time Gohan still went even with Dabra as a Super Saiyan and the guy (Dabra) was said to be around Perfect Cell level.
 

NeonZ

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 28, 2017
9,370
It seems the editor seems to have a 'if Toriyama okays it, it much be good' because they never mentioned any corrections they did. Meantime, Toriyama wants Toyo to be more creative and mostly fixes art and gags with very few story criticisms. The last time on record we had Toriyama address a story point in the manga is him fixing Toyo's version of Shin.

There were still some known changes during the ToP too, like rejecting Toyo's pages that showed Belmod and his angel flirting. Toriyama also rewrote the interactions of Ribrianne with the main cast (and he was also the one that added the bit with the arms of her two partners extending to wrap 18 rather than just making them hold her). We don't know about anything from later into the ToP or during the current arc though.
 

HeroR

Banned
Dec 10, 2017
7,450
Nope, future Gohan is really that weak. He would still go down in one hit. Remember that in the movie Gohan took out a guy who was giving Piccolo trouble in one hit, and Piccolo is far stronger than the Androids were. Future Gohan couldn't beat the Androids.

You have to remember that peace time Gohan still went even with Dabra as a Super Saiyan and the guy (Dabra) was said to be around Perfect Cell level.

That and depending on the source, Future Gohan was only about as strong as Namek Saga Super Saiyan Goku. And in the retelling of Resurrection 'F', Gohan is stronger than his movie counterpart since he took out Ginyu-Togama with two hits as a Super Saiyan who was stronger than normal Tagoma who tanked a punch from Piccolo and ripped his arm off. In fact, retelling implied base Gohan was stronger than Piccolo.

TLDR: Future Gohan is fodder.
 

HeroR

Banned
Dec 10, 2017
7,450
There were still some known changes during the ToP too, like rejecting Toyo's pages that showed Belmod and his angel flirting. Toriyama also rewrote the interactions of Ribrianne with the main cast (and he was also the one that added the bit with the arms of her two partners extending to wrap 18 rather than just making them hold her). We don't know about anything from later into the ToP or during the current arc though.

Good points I forgot about. Strangely, it's around this time that we haven't learned if Toriyama fixed the story script that Toyo's writing went off a cliff. Like compare how he writes Goku in the Future Trunks Saga and even the beginning of the Universal Survival Saga to how he writes Goku from the TOP onwards. Yeah, his Goku wasn't great since he doubled down on the 'Goku is a bad father', but his writing with Goku and other characters have been getting worst.
 

Comrade Grogu

Banned
Jun 20, 2020
4,090
Good points I forgot about. Strangely, it's around this time that we haven't learned if Toriyama fixed the story script that Toyo's writing went off a cliff. Like compare how he writes Goku in the Future Trunks Saga and even the beginning of the Universal Survival Saga to how he writes Goku from the TOP onwards. Yeah, his Goku wasn't great since he doubled down on the 'Goku is a bad father', but his writing with Goku and other characters have been getting worst.
Vegeta is a bad father.

Change my mind.
 

Skeeter49

I wish Jim Ryan would eat me
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,295
I don't think they'll ever commit to an official canon between the manga and anime. Viz will call the manga canon at times, to help promote the manga, and Toei will call the anime canon at times to help promote the anime, but an official and universal canon, I doubt we'll get that.
 

Cordy

Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,303
Just read the spoilers that released today and wow...this fucking manga keeps getting worse and worse.

If you thought it was bad days ago when we first got the spoilers then fuck its even worse now.
 
Last edited:

Noppie

Member
Oct 27, 2017
13,750
Inb4
Moro evaporates immediately upon using Merus' power, because copying Merus made him an Angel and him using the powers for evil go against the Angel's code
 

HeroR

Banned
Dec 10, 2017
7,450
I'm beginning to wonder if Toyo is stalling. This arc feels like it should have ended months ago.
 

HeroR

Banned
Dec 10, 2017
7,450
This is Super 17 tier bad but at least Super 17 had the decency to be short

Well, Moro is Omega with being a walking Dragon Ball villain reference with no irony. But like Super 17, he also didn't stay long enough to be anything but boring.

At this point, I'm not sure if I should be more annoyed at Toyo or his editor.
 

The Silver

Member
Oct 28, 2017
10,703
The DB formula of bad guy constantly bullshitting a new power up really does not play well with monthly format pacing.....and you know the fact this whole is poorly recreating DBZ's greatest hits without understanding why the worked in the first place. For the love of Dende someone kill this bootleg fake goat Cell fuck

Super actually didn't use that typical villain formula a lot besides with Black
 

Big One

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,277
DId anyone see that interview with the V-Jump editor "Victory" Uchida? Gives a lot of details on the actual creative proccess that's involved with creating the manga. It was originally a video but here's the bulletpoints translated (copy and pasted from reddit):
  • Uchida says that he works out the story alongside Toriyama and Toyotaro
  • Toyotaro turns in the storyboards to ed.
  • Ed. passes on the storyboard to Toriyama for one more check
  • Toyotaro's storyboards are unusually detailed because of this extra Toriyama check
  • Uchida and his co-host mention that Page 8 (the last page published to the official site as a preview) acts as a cliffhanger, with a twist/reveal on Page 9
  • His cohost also has a copy of the entire chapter's storyboard, and marvels at the cunning of cutting the preview off on Page 8
  • The story is basically at its climax
  • This story wrapping up means a new one is going to have to start soon
  • There's a story meeting scheduled for two days after recording (like either 10/15 or 10/16 then)
  • The plan/norm at this stage is just to narrow down general ideas with Toriyama and Toyotaro
  • Uchida says it's basically like narrowing ten options down to three (the scope of these options—whether entire storyline premises or details—isn't specified; seems more like it's brought up to give a general impression of early story meetings)
  • Everyone agrees that "Migatte no Gokui" (English name: Ultra Instinct) is a very cool name
  • The cohost talks about Ultra Instinct as if it debuted in the manga first; oops. Uchida rolls with it.
  • Uchida references talking about "having him (Goku) progress in this kind of direction" during a story meeting, sometime early during UI's conception
  • In those initial discussions on Migatte no Gokui, Uchida did not expect it would come with a major appearance change; Toriyama's silver-haired design came as a surprise
  • Uchida references the cool expression on Toriyama's UI illustration (Is this just his Battle of Gods Super Saiyan God recolor illustration we've seen?)
  • They talk about the clever pun of "Migatte no Gokui" (using the characters making up "migatte," a word for "selfish" literally, to express the idea of the body moving of its own accord)
  • "Power balance" of story meetings: Toriyama: 100 million; Toyotaro: 10 million: Uchida: -100
  • There's a real sense of "compatibility" between Toriyama and Toyotaro
  • Their ideas don't seem to clash with one another
  • They tend to simply agree with the others' ideas and build off of them (seems like a "yes, and" sort of thing; though this is also a very polite PR presentation of the meetings, so who knows)
  • A second meeting metaphor: Toriyama: Goku; Toyotaro: Vegeta; Uchida: Yamcha
  • Uchida says he feels lucky to be present at those meetings as a fan himself
  • Volume 14 is out on 12/4, and covers up through the September issue's chapter
Toriyama seems to still have a ton of involvement with the story of the manga.
 
Oct 25, 2017
12,319
DId anyone see that interview with the V-Jump editor "Victory" Uchida? Gives a lot of details on the actual creative proccess that's involved with creating the manga. It was originally a video but here's the bulletpoints translated (copy and pasted from reddit):
  • Uchida says that he works out the story alongside Toriyama and Toyotaro
  • Toyotaro turns in the storyboards to ed.
  • Ed. passes on the storyboard to Toriyama for one more check
  • Toyotaro's storyboards are unusually detailed because of this extra Toriyama check
  • Uchida and his co-host mention that Page 8 (the last page published to the official site as a preview) acts as a cliffhanger, with a twist/reveal on Page 9
  • His cohost also has a copy of the entire chapter's storyboard, and marvels at the cunning of cutting the preview off on Page 8
  • The story is basically at its climax
  • This story wrapping up means a new one is going to have to start soon
  • There's a story meeting scheduled for two days after recording (like either 10/15 or 10/16 then)
  • The plan/norm at this stage is just to narrow down general ideas with Toriyama and Toyotaro
  • Uchida says it's basically like narrowing ten options down to three (the scope of these options—whether entire storyline premises or details—isn't specified; seems more like it's brought up to give a general impression of early story meetings)
  • Everyone agrees that "Migatte no Gokui" (English name: Ultra Instinct) is a very cool name
  • The cohost talks about Ultra Instinct as if it debuted in the manga first; oops. Uchida rolls with it.
  • Uchida references talking about "having him (Goku) progress in this kind of direction" during a story meeting, sometime early during UI's conception
  • In those initial discussions on Migatte no Gokui, Uchida did not expect it would come with a major appearance change; Toriyama's silver-haired design came as a surprise
  • Uchida references the cool expression on Toriyama's UI illustration (Is this just his Battle of Gods Super Saiyan God recolor illustration we've seen?)
  • They talk about the clever pun of "Migatte no Gokui" (using the characters making up "migatte," a word for "selfish" literally, to express the idea of the body moving of its own accord)
  • "Power balance" of story meetings: Toriyama: 100 million; Toyotaro: 10 million: Uchida: -100
  • There's a real sense of "compatibility" between Toriyama and Toyotaro
  • Their ideas don't seem to clash with one another
  • They tend to simply agree with the others' ideas and build off of them (seems like a "yes, and" sort of thing; though this is also a very polite PR presentation of the meetings, so who knows)
  • A second meeting metaphor: Toriyama: Goku; Toyotaro: Vegeta; Uchida: Yamcha
  • Uchida says he feels lucky to be present at those meetings as a fan himself
  • Volume 14 is out on 12/4, and covers up through the September issue's chapter
Toriyama seems to still have a ton of involvement with the story of the manga.
I'm sure Toriyama is as involved with the manga as he is with his taxes.