no
you should be consuming content not because its highly rated but because it appeals to you.
discovery should be organic, not based on lists of stuff everyone likes.
Nicely summarized.Doesn't bother me. Just because it's critically acclaimed doesn't mean I'll even like it.
Honestly, I play every critically acclaimed game. I'm crazy like that. Took a gander at that list in the op and there are only 10 or so that I haven't.
All this.Doesn't bother me. Just because it's critically acclaimed doesn't mean I'll even like it. I make time to play the games I really want, which is only a small handful each year, and I don't worry about the rest.