• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Trup1aya

Literally a train safety expert
Member
Oct 25, 2017
21,323
I felt like the plot and characteristics were fine.

Where the movie faltered was the script. Just way too much exposition
 

Hobbun

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,394
Just watched this movie this last night and enjoyed it overall, but did not like the ending at all or what they had done with Wanda.

I did watch WandaVision, so it does make sense on the route they were heading with the Darkhold. But I had hoped
it was something she would have gotten help with eventually instead of her becoming a mass murderer because she is so consumed with grief and focused on getting her children back

It just seems they are deadset on finishing off Avenger Wanda one way or another. Even if she survived, she has done way too much to be forgiven for. I had liked her as an Avenger and it really seems that path has closed now, which I am not happy about.

But I really don't know what Elizabeth Olson's contract is at (amount of movies). Maybe she isn't interested in continuing.

Just disappointing either way.

And I know the thread is marked SPOILERS, but post is chock-full of end movie spoilers so I marked it, anyways.
 

Lotus

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
105,642
Just watched this movie this last night and enjoyed it overall, but did not like the ending at all or what they had done with Wanda.

I did watch WandaVision, so it does make sense on the route they were heading with the Darkhold. But I had hoped
it was something she would have gotten help with eventually instead of her becoming a mass murderer because she is so consumed with grief and focused on getting her children back

It just seems they are deadset on finishing off Avenger Wanda one way or another. Even if she survived, she has done way too much to be forgiven for. I had liked her as an Avenger and it really seems that path has closed now, which I am not happy about.

But I really don't know what Elizabeth Olson's contract is at (amount of movies). Maybe she isn't interested in continuing.

Just disappointing either way.

And I know the thread is marked SPOILERS, but post is chock-full of end movie spoilers so I marked it, anyways.

Elizabeth has already confirmed she's very much still interested in the role, and pretty much talks as if it's all but guaranteed Wanda is still alive
 

Parthenios

The Fallen
Oct 28, 2017
13,601
The biggest (only?) laugh in my theater was when they introduced themselves as the Illuminati.

My group thought it was way to violent for the children we'd brought. I sort of already knew that but knew my kids were fine with it, but some of the others spent like the last half of the movie with their eyes closed (they seemed especially afraid of the souls of the damned). Their parents were agitated because of how much of a departure this was from normal MCU stuff.

It seemed to me that 838 Strange hadn't actually caused that Incursion but Bad Strange had instead? Amd the Illuminati wrongly executed him?
 

Surakian

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
10,816
I don't like the direction they took with Wanda but I also enjoyed it for what it was.

The horror elements were fantastic.
 

golguin

Member
Oct 29, 2017
3,757
Finished watching movie. I thought it was okay. I enjoyed watching America Chavez. She's a huge deal for Mexican representation.

Her line at the start of the movie calling Dr Strange "wey" is my biggest laugh of any Marvel movie.
 

Tavernade

Tavernade
Moderator
Sep 18, 2018
8,617
Elizabeth has already confirmed she's very much still interested in the role, and pretty much talks as if it's all but guaranteed Wanda is still alive

Wanda seems so ridiculously popular with fans that there's no way she's gone for long, yeah. Whether its 616 Wanda or a Variant that returns.

We also have that Agatha show coming, and unless there's a summary I missed it'd be an obvious spot to bring her back in.
 

GreenMamba

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,289
So if incursions can be caused by messing with alternate universes too much you'd think the 616 universe is potentially in peril considering what happened in No Way Home.
 

Mancha

alt account
Banned
Oct 23, 2021
2,520
Wanda seems so ridiculously popular with fans that there's no way she's gone for long, yeah. Whether its 616 Wanda or a Variant that returns.

We also have that Agatha show coming, and unless there's a summary I missed it'd be an obvious spot to bring her back in.
I'm dead certain that we are getting Earth 616 Wanda not just back, but a full blown film or new series featuring her. It's absolute madness to me how much popular she got thanks to Elizabeth Olsen.

So if incursions can be caused by messing with alternate universes too much you'd think the 616 universe is potentially in peril considering what happened in No Way Home.
Yes, very much so. And just like in all the other timelines, it's Strange's fault.
 

Dabanton

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,910
I'd love it if we got that. Give her a redemption arc, girl deserves it.

Lol how do you get redemption after what she got up to in the movie? In fact she was even more brutal than any other villain when we look at how she cut a swathe through people. And this version was apprently the tamed down version.

Better to keep her as an agent of chaos, she can't for me be a 'hero' again.
 

Mancha

alt account
Banned
Oct 23, 2021
2,520
I'd love it if we got that. Give her a redemption arc, girl deserves it.
Lol how do you get redemption after what she got up to in the movie? In fact she was even more brutal than any other villain when we look at how she cut a swathe through people. And this version was apprently the tamed down version.

Better to keep her as an agent of chaos, she can't for me be a 'hero' again.
Redemption might be too strong of an word, but we need to remember that we are talking about arguably one of the most powerful characters in the MCU getting corrupted by the Darkhold and doing awful things, and she lives in an world where two Captains America have as one of their best friends a former brainwashed Hydra assassin that also did unspeakable things.

It's in the very DNA of Marvel to have character fall from grace and then make a come back.
 

GreenMamba

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,289
The only way I can see Wanda getting a redemption arc is if they pull a Mandarin style retcon and establish that she was actually under the direct control of Cthon in Multiverse of Madness or something, but I can't see that working.
 

Mancha

alt account
Banned
Oct 23, 2021
2,520
The only way I can see Wanda getting a redemption arc is if they pull a Mandarin style retcon and establish that she was actually under the direct control of Cthon in Multiverse of Madness or something, but I can't see that working.
…she was literally corrupted by the Darkhold. What are you talking about, it's right there in the film. There is nothing to retcon there.
 

GreenMamba

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,289
…she was literally corrupted by the Darkhold. What are you talking about, it's right there in the film. There is nothing to retcon there.
I mean in the sense that she was literally not in control of her actions. The Darkhold, from what I gathered, only corrupts what was already there and makes it worse. Per Wanda, it tempted her.

I mean retconned in the sense that if it's revealed that Cthon or someone was basically literally puppeteering her body and she had nothing to do with it.
 

Callibretto

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,491
Indonesia
Lol how do you get redemption after what she got up to in the movie? In fact she was even more brutal than any other villain when we look at how she cut a swathe through people. And this version was apprently the tamed down version.

Better to keep her as an agent of chaos, she can't for me be a 'hero' again.
By introducing even bigger threat and have Wanda show up to save the day, as long as she didn't act smug about it and look remorseful for what she'd done, I think it'll be fine
 
Oct 8, 2019
9,126
When the X-men show up I am sure they are going to do something to establish that connection with Magneto and Polaris.

FHOqYFzXsBYD59J
 
Oct 25, 2017
32,274
Atlanta GA
So if incursions can be caused by messing with alternate universes too much you'd think the 616 universe is potentially in peril considering what happened in No Way Home.

Nothing ever good comes of messing with time and reality. In the comics the heroes of the 616 Universe learned that the hard way when the incursions began. There had been numerous major events in the preceding years that involved fucking around with spacetime.

I mean in the sense that she was literally not in control of her actions. The Darkhold, from what I gathered, only corrupts what was already there and makes it worse. Per Wanda, it tempted her.

I mean retconned in the sense that if it's revealed that Cthon or someone was basically literally puppeteering her body and she had nothing to do with it.

No it's definitely not like that and I don't think they've left it open to that possibility in the future. Wanda was willfully doing those things. But it was the Darkhold's influence that was telling her it didn't really matter, not to worry about the consequences, that she'll get everything she wants and be happy if she just does what she needs to do and kills anyone in her way. It doesn't mind control the user or anything it merely goads them into doing evil things with the power it offers. In the name of chaos and darkness and all that jazz. It's a book of hell written by a demon and it bears a malignant force.

Wanda's not a pure of heart superhero and that's a good thing. She has the capacity to be cruel and do great evil. She does right under the influence of someone like Clint or Vision who understand what she's going through and want to see her at her best, she can swing to the other end when someone like Ultron or something like the Darkhold just sees her as a vessel for committing evil. That they've illustrated that quite clearly throughout her character arc is a really great thing to see.

By introducing even bigger threat and have Wanda show up to save the day, as long as she didn't act smug about it and look remorseful for what she'd done, I think it'll be fine

Yeah she may not be on a team but Strange would at least vouch for her in that she's not purely evil or anything and that she had already done the right thing by destroying the Darkhold when she was able to think clearly. And they need someone as powerful as her.
 
Last edited:

Mancha

alt account
Banned
Oct 23, 2021
2,520
I mean in the sense that she was literally not in control of her actions. The Darkhold, from what I gathered, only corrupts what was already there and makes it worse. Per Wanda, it tempted her.

I mean retconned in the sense that if it's revealed that Cthon or someone was basically literally puppeteering her body and she had nothing to do with it.
The Darkhold isn't Erskine's Super Serum that fucked up the Red Skull but made Steve Rogers a super soldier. There is no good things coming from reading the Book of the Damned, Wanda was corrupted and while America managed to make her confront what she became, Strange by engaging with the Darkhold is also fucked. There will be consequences for what he did too, in fact it's heavily hinted that the incursion that Strange caused might doom Earth 616 and that third eye isn't good news.
 
Oct 25, 2017
6,709
Wanda killed some sorcerers who knew the deal when they got their sling rings and some heroes in another dimension. She wasn't running around nyc herself at the start of the movie. She's good to scrub, just like strange in 838, the public doesn't need to know the truth.

What id love is for her for get redeemed over a series or movie only to have an incursion of alt heroes from 838 seek to capture and put her on trial.
 

Mancha

alt account
Banned
Oct 23, 2021
2,520
Wanda killed some sorcerers who knew the deal when they got their sling rings and some heroes in another dimension. She wasn't running around nyc herself at the start of the movie. She's good to scrub, just like strange in 838, the public doesn't need to know the truth.

What id love is for her for get redeemed over a series or movie only to have an incursion of alt heroes from 838 seek to capture and put her on trial.
That would be CRAZY cool, I love how much directions the MCU has opened up.
 

Lump

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
15,961
Soon everyone is going to start having dreams of some Kang person fucking their day up and they won't be able to explain it.
 

Dalek

Member
Oct 25, 2017
38,901
Finally saw it. I like a lot of it but I felt it was very rushed and slightly rough around the edges script wise. But man all the Incursion talk got me excited.
 

Mancha

alt account
Banned
Oct 23, 2021
2,520
Honestly, while that seems cool, I don't see how it would work logically. "So this lady just came in and soloed the best heroes we got. Time to go hunt her down with the Great Lakes avengers."
She doesn't have access to the Darkhold anymore. So while she is powerful, she likely isn't as powerful as she was in the Multiverse of Madness. Also, it's heavily hinted that Earth 838's Illuminati are a bunch of assholes that ran a police state type of heroism. They hunting Scarlet Witch and declaring war to Earth 616 seem like logical next steps, it's not like the Illuminati's whole purpose in the Hickman's Avengers run wasn't to stop incursions by annihilating other Earths.
 

Tavernade

Tavernade
Moderator
Sep 18, 2018
8,617
Redemption might be too strong of an word, but we need to remember that we are talking about arguably one of the most powerful characters in the MCU getting corrupted by the Darkhold and doing awful things, and she lives in an world where two Captains America have as one of their best friends a former brainwashed Hydra assassin that also did unspeakable things.

It's in the very DNA of Marvel to have character fall from grace and then make a come back.

My biggest issue with the movie is, at least to me, they didn't bring the Darkhold to the forefront as the sorta 'actual' villain as much as it should have if her actions were primarily due to it. Like, there's a pretty big gap between asking America nicely to use her powers (and upon finding out she's not able, training her to use them) and sending giant monsters to kill her. It's less clear than with Bucky, who seemed to have little to no free will at all as the Winter Soldier.

Honestly, while that seems cool, I don't see how it would work logically. "So this lady just came in and soloed the best heroes we got. Time to go hunt her down with the Great Lakes avengers."

I don't think we know enough about the universe to know if that's true. I'm not super aware of the comics version of the Illuminati, but my understanding was that they were more brains than brawn. They also didn't really go in prepared for what was coming to them (Mr. Fantastic and Carter had little chance against her powerset, if they knew what was coming I think the others may have been able to pull something off). They could easily have a bunch of other heroes and send a team over explicitly trained for Wanda's powerset, as strong as it is. Like, I imagine Jean Grey would still be hanging out over there? They might even still have a Vision.
 

Mancha

alt account
Banned
Oct 23, 2021
2,520
My biggest issue with the movie is, at least to me, they didn't bring the Darkhold to the forefront as the sorta 'actual' villain as much as it should have if her actions were primarily due to it. Like, there's a pretty big gap between asking America nicely to use her powers (and upon finding out she's not able, training her to use them) and sending giant monsters to kill her. It's less clear than with Bucky, who seemed to have little to no free will at all as the Winter Soldier.

I really like Waldron's line of thought when it comes making Wanda a full blown antagonist. If she wasn't the antagonist, she wouldn't be the protagonist either, because that was a Doctor Strange film after all. We know that the Book of the Damned corrupted Wanda and what she did as the Scarlet Witch is an weight that she will have to carry, that makes her for a more interesting character for me.

My favorite part of this movie was when you introduce the alternate-Earth heroes of the Illuminati — and then promptly have Wanda slaughter them, which freaked out some fans. Where did that idea come from?
Yeah, that's a blast. That's probably my favorite sequence in the movie. The idea for that was not in my outline; I was writing the first draft and I guess I felt like, as I put it, the movie needed to get drunk. It felt like we're at the point where I need to find the madness in the multiverse here. I had no idea: Would I be able to use these characters? Would this even be possible? But I knew with Sam [Raimi] that if we did it this way, it would be amazing. And so I wrote it in.

I was watching Aliens a lot as I was writing. Because just tonally this movie is a thriller and a [feature-length] chase. I just love how Aliens goes to great lengths to tell you how badass the space Marines are — and then they just get slaughtered. Then you are really scared of the Xenomorphs for the rest of that movie, and that's what I wanted to accomplish with Wanda. At the end of that Illuminati sequence. I hope you were truly terrified of the Scarlet Witch. It's been awesome being in the theater hearing the cheers, then the gasps and the groans. [Laughs] I mean, you know, people were feeling something at the movies. That's good!

What was your thinking behind having Wanda Maximoff become a full-in villain in this movie, especially since it's a bit of a change in course from WandaVision?
Well, first off, it's true to who the comics' version of the character is and what she does in the comics. It was always where Wanda was headed in the MCU, even as I inherited the movie. The question just became, when would it happen? Certainly, there was a version of this movie where Wanda was part of the ensemble that ended, I guess, with her turning bad, and then she could have been an antagonist of another movie. But I feel like in that case, you would have had a watered-down version of Wanda going bad because it's still Dr. Strange's movie. She wouldn't be the protagonist, and she wouldn't really be the antagonist. You'd have to have a [different] antagonist throughout the entirety of most of the film.

You know, she's doing bad stuff throughout WandaVision. She does make the heroic choice to let go of all those people. But it's also revealed to her that the family she's built is not real. Then she gets the Darkhold at the end of the series and learns that there is a real version of her children out there. And if you've got the Book of the Damned whispering in your ear long enough that your kids are out there and you could go get 'em, maybe that can push you to do some terrible things.

www.rollingstone.com

'Multiverse of Madness' Screenwriter Wanted Tom Cruise to Play An Alternate Iron Man

"I asked: Could we get Tom Cruise's Iron Man?" Screenwriter Michael Waldron spills the beans on 'Dr. Strange in the Multiverse of Madness.'
 
Oct 25, 2017
1,281
The biggest missed opportunity was not having Vision in this. The dude is alive and has his old memories and she's seemingly "killed off" and he's nowhere to be seen?
 

9wilds

Member
Jan 1, 2022
3,562
Just watched this movie this last night and enjoyed it overall, but did not like the ending at all or what they had done with Wanda.

I did watch WandaVision, so it does make sense on the route they were heading with the Darkhold. But I had hoped
it was something she would have gotten help with eventually instead of her becoming a mass murderer because she is so consumed with grief and focused on getting her children back

It just seems they are deadset on finishing off Avenger Wanda one way or another. Even if she survived, she has done way too much to be forgiven for. I had liked her as an Avenger and it really seems that path has closed now, which I am not happy about.

But I really don't know what Elizabeth Olson's contract is at (amount of movies). Maybe she isn't interested in continuing.

Just disappointing either way.

And I know the thread is marked SPOILERS, but post is chock-full of end movie spoilers so I marked it, anyways.

The Darkhold isn't something that just made a good person bad. It amplified and tempted her dark thoughts, but she did them. She'll have to own that.

As far as her redemption, on 616 that should be possible. She hasn't killed too many people here. No one even knows she massacred the Illuminati, though Strange will know she did some damage.

She can be redeemed if she finds happiness. And she will. Because the Illuminati will come for her and she must be sympathetic to the audience and the 616 heroes.
 

GreenMamba

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,289
Thinking about all of the known ways to traverse the multiverse in the MCU:

1. The Avenger's quantum time bridge. A borderline case as it is limited to alternate universes that come into existence due to the timeline branches the technology itself causes.
2. The TVA's tempad technology. This is also (seemingly) limited in the TVA's hands, accessing only the "sacred timeline" and branches therein, though He Who Remains and his variants presumably used the same kind of tech to traverse each others' realities.
3. The Watcher has this ability innately, as he's a god like being that exists in a domain outside of the multiverse and is capable of viewing, entering, and pulling people and objects from them at a whim.
4. Infinity Ultron was also capable of doing this once he became aware of the Watcher's existence. Not clear if other beings with all six Infinity Stones could have done this too or not.
5. The corrupted Doctor Strange from What If...? summoned the zombies from their universe during the fight against Infinity Ultron. It's not clear if this is something he is able to do on his own or if it was with the Watcher's cooperation.
6. The Runes of Kof-Kol, the spell that Strange attempted to use to make people forget Spider-Man's identity, ended up inadvertently pulling in nine different beings into the 616 universe (including the symbiote) when it backfired before it was contained. Not intentional and possibly not repeatable.
7. America Chavez has the power to open rifts in space that lead to different universes.
8. Dreamwalking allows the user to possess an alternate version of themselves in another universe, but this is forbidden magic written in the Darkhold that comes with a heavy toll on the user.

-Possible but technically unconfirmed case: Clea likely can traverse the multiverse as she knows Strange caused an incursion and told him to come with her to fix it.

It's actually pretty difficult to move across the multiverse in the MCU thus far, and for those in the 616 universe America is basically the only real option.
 
Last edited:

Parthenios

The Fallen
Oct 28, 2017
13,601
I wonder what was different in 838 that made Ultron work as intended? Presumably Loki still attacked Earth and motivated Stark to build a suit of armor around the world, and Hydra still stole the scepter and gave Wanda powers. Maybe 838 Vision took over the Ultron bots after Sokovia? Or maybe Ultron never turned evil, but then how did Wanda get from a European Hydra base to an American suburb? Is Pietro still alive?

Multiverses are fun!
 

Callibretto

Member
Oct 25, 2017
9,491
Indonesia
I wonder what was different in 838 that made Ultron work as intended? Presumably Loki still attacked Earth and motivated Stark to build a suit of armor around the world, and Hydra still stole the scepter and gave Wanda powers. Maybe 838 Vision took over the Ultron bots after Sokovia? Or maybe Ultron never turned evil, but then how did Wanda get from a European Hydra base to an American suburb? Is Pietro still alive?

Multiverses are fun!
Maybe because they have smartest man in the world Reed in 838 universe
 
Oct 25, 2017
32,274
Atlanta GA
Yeah, they need to bring back the Illuminati. They were so overconfident and just got yamcha'd

The 616 will have its own illuminati eventually.

The illuminati are supposed to be a troubled bunch and not as immune to fault as they think they are. It was a really good interpretation of what the group would look like in another universe.

Maybe because they have smartest man in the world Reed in 838 universe

Or Ultron was built by Hank Pym correctly
 
Oct 25, 2017
12,584
Arizona
I wonder what was different in 838 that made Ultron work as intended? Presumably Loki still attacked Earth and motivated Stark to build a suit of armor around the world, and Hydra still stole the scepter and gave Wanda powers. Maybe 838 Vision took over the Ultron bots after Sokovia? Or maybe Ultron never turned evil, but then how did Wanda get from a European Hydra base to an American suburb? Is Pietro still alive?

Multiverses are fun!
Probably not having that Stark influence.
 

jph139

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,365
I think the "where's Tony Stark?" question is the biggest one in 838 - most of the other characters you can explain as being off-world (Thor, the Guardians) or not being "leader" types (Hulk, Widow, Hawkeye, Ant-Man, so on), but it's tough to imagine a world where the Illuminati exists, he's an active hero, and he's not a part of it. And so many events in the MCU spill out of the various things that Stark fucked with.

Did he die at some point? Turn evil? Never born, or never became Iron Man? On sabbatical? There is that one extra chair at the end...

"What's Wakanda up to?" is the other big one, but I'd assume they're probably in a Cold War with whatever power structure the Illuminati has set up.
 

GreenMamba

Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,289
Wasn't the MCU not supposed to be 616 prior to this movie? Like it had it's own number
Earth-199999, but this was never mentioned in the films and was created to contextualize the MCU within the comics' multiverse. This film makes it pretty clear that the films ignore this context and do not consider themselves beholden to any multiversal world building in the comics.
 

JaseC64

Enlightened
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
11,008
Strong Island NY
Yo this movie was DAMN good. Better than anything prior. It's like the opposite of No Way Home in a dark way.

I avoided leaks and was surprised at Reed Richard's and Xavior. OMFG! DaYUM.

Sadly they had a bad time. Wanda is TOO OP. I think something will need to be done about that lol. (Maybe moot by now)

Ok can someone explain why Strange 838 was executed? I mean he was dream walking doing exactly what? Was it the 3rd eye evil one who he mind controlled and caused an incursion there? But I understood they had to axe him because he used the book or some shit. That I need explanation.
 

nicolasacmf

Avenger
Oct 27, 2017
1,515
I think the "where's Tony Stark?" question is the biggest one in 838 - most of the other characters you can explain as being off-world (Thor, the Guardians) or not being "leader" types (Hulk, Widow, Hawkeye, Ant-Man, so on), but it's tough to imagine a world where the Illuminati exists, he's an active hero, and he's not a part of it. And so many events in the MCU spill out of the various things that Stark fucked with.

Did he die at some point? Turn evil? Never born, or never became Iron Man? On sabbatical? There is that one extra chair at the end...

green-goblin-spider-man-no-way-home.gif
 

KamenSenshi

Member
Nov 27, 2017
1,861
I wonder what was different in 838 that made Ultron work as intended? Presumably Loki still attacked Earth and motivated Stark to build a suit of armor around the world, and Hydra still stole the scepter and gave Wanda powers. Maybe 838 Vision took over the Ultron bots after Sokovia? Or maybe Ultron never turned evil, but then how did Wanda get from a European Hydra base to an American suburb? Is Pietro still alive?

Multiverses are fun!
If they never used the mind stone then Ultron works as intended.
 

Rydeen

Member
Oct 25, 2017
1,499
Seattle, WA.
Ok can someone explain why Strange 838 was executed? I mean he was dream walking doing exactly what? Was it the 3rd eye evil one who he mind controlled and caused an incursion there? But I understood they had to axe him because he used the book or some shit. That I need explanation.
Based on Strange's little "chat" with Mordo when they were in the room alone together, I almost have the feeling Mordo used dark magic or even the Darkhold itself to manipulate the Illuminati in that universe to kill Strange so he could assume Sorcerer Supreme.
 
Last edited: