Will I eventually? Yes I plan to play it on the hardest difficulty because the gameplay is simply
perfect.
Story-wise? Meh. I can take it or leave it. I have a less favorable opinion on it as time goes on simply because the first's ending to me was perfect and my favorite game ending of all time because of how relatively open-ended it was. The existence of a sequel that follows Ellie and Joel at all by definition renounces the open-endedness of the original's ending, which to me lessens it. Regardless if you feel that the ending of the first was clearly what they followed up with in Part 2, I didn't want that confirmation. I liked being able to consider the possibility that things went a different way.
It doesn't help that the ending of Part 2 also tries to do the whole open-ended ending thing, and it feels unearned in comparison. It's not an awful game, the story isn't really bad, but
section is pretty undercooked and I had trouble empathizing with most of them. I get what they tried to do, and I respect the attempt to turn things on their head a bit, but it wasn't executed well enough and I know I'm going to dread it somewhat on my replaythrough.