To give a rundown on how I feel about this game personally, you have to know what games I like and what games I don't, that i compare it to.
I consider Bloodborne and Nier Automata to be the best PS4 experiences I had. I didn't enjoy Uncharted 4 and wasn't interested in stuff like God of War and I didn't like Spider-Man. I need a mix of good gameplay but with special emphasis on storytelling in games I like on a higher level than "I liked it". I feel this game is the best game, based on its first 3 hours, on PS4 since Bloodborne and Nier Automata, in a mix of what it does graphically and narratively. The gameplay isn't the strongest pull but the atmosphere and world draws me in so that I like to explore. The "social strand" system also puts a smile on my face, and it's a genuine help.
Playing on Hard Mode with zero prior experience has been easy with no deaths so far. The first stealth segment, I nailed it by being very slow and cautious, and it felt appropriately tense, thanks to good visual feedback, the stamina system and especially good audio/music.
I'm on the honeymoon but this game feels like Christmas in a way I haven't felt since I got my hands on Mass Effect 3.