You've mentioned neutral twice now, do you mean null? Kits getting riled up seems feels a little townish to me
-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
Death Stranding Mafia |OT| Bridge the Divides in Society (Via Murder)
- Thread starter Natiko
- Start date
Null yes, I see nothing from Kits that sways me to suspect her as scum but by the same token I'd like to see more from her before I decide to lean town
That's just my current scum reads. No votes for Mao doesn't mean he's not scum.
It's definitely not set in stone but at the moment I don't have any better leads. I was also considering Kits for a while but her latest burst of activity put her back out of the scum lean territory.
Seconded. If someone is banned they will probably be replaced, so it's a concern for the gamerunner.
Catching up.
Kitsunelaine - Mild town read, though few interactions, but spot probably replaced, so nothing much to say here.
Fran - Honestly, null. I see some people putting Fran down as town and I would maybe give that a slight edge for questions and engagement but Fran seems mild here compared to games I've played with him in the past and that rings some alarm bells for me. Would not vote today but very much on my watch list.
Maolfunction - Really all there is here is the noise generated by a random vote, which is NAI. Null pending more activity.
malus - Hesitant town lean. malus is often in the background but nothing cagey here so far, though I might do a reread this afternoon just in case.
Fat4All - Fatdog is a tough read but I don't think I'd vote d1. Scum Fat4all tends to try to blend more so my lean here is slight town.
Kalor - I truly have no idea. Feels a little opportunistic but I can rarely read Kalor even as days progress. I don't think I've EVER read him correctly. Solid null, possible scum lean if turmoil happens to be town.
Ketkat - Light on content, but town lean
Vincent Alexander - Nothing whatsoever. Would vote. Poor game entry followed by disappearance feels more scummy than not to me.
Kopite - Town lean, would not vote today.
turmoil7 - Have posted at length on turmoil and the back peddling about me+Fran being a joke doesn't fly with me. Scum.
Meatwad - Null for now, but a little more engagement today that I want to watch as we move into end of day.
Fandorin - Faint scum lean, but honestly would not vote Fando d1 because some of it just seems like it might be odd phrasing/difference of approach. I'd definitely rather see how he develops over another phase.
Gorlak - Feeling like Gorlak and I were just talking past each other, so I'll file him as not-a-vote for now but don't really have a proper read as yet, pending further developments.
Fantomas - Some weirdness settling in but as the day has progressed, has felt very town - not just meta town, but engaging, curious town.
Fran - Honestly, null. I see some people putting Fran down as town and I would maybe give that a slight edge for questions and engagement but Fran seems mild here compared to games I've played with him in the past and that rings some alarm bells for me. Would not vote today but very much on my watch list.
Maolfunction - Really all there is here is the noise generated by a random vote, which is NAI. Null pending more activity.
malus - Hesitant town lean. malus is often in the background but nothing cagey here so far, though I might do a reread this afternoon just in case.
Fat4All - Fatdog is a tough read but I don't think I'd vote d1. Scum Fat4all tends to try to blend more so my lean here is slight town.
Kalor - I truly have no idea. Feels a little opportunistic but I can rarely read Kalor even as days progress. I don't think I've EVER read him correctly. Solid null, possible scum lean if turmoil happens to be town.
Ketkat - Light on content, but town lean
Vincent Alexander - Nothing whatsoever. Would vote. Poor game entry followed by disappearance feels more scummy than not to me.
Kopite - Town lean, would not vote today.
turmoil7 - Have posted at length on turmoil and the back peddling about me+Fran being a joke doesn't fly with me. Scum.
Meatwad - Null for now, but a little more engagement today that I want to watch as we move into end of day.
Fandorin - Faint scum lean, but honestly would not vote Fando d1 because some of it just seems like it might be odd phrasing/difference of approach. I'd definitely rather see how he develops over another phase.
Gorlak - Feeling like Gorlak and I were just talking past each other, so I'll file him as not-a-vote for now but don't really have a proper read as yet, pending further developments.
Fantomas - Some weirdness settling in but as the day has progressed, has felt very town - not just meta town, but engaging, curious town.
I'm stealing Fran's list who stole it from Fantomas :
Would Vote Today:
Kalor
Meatwad
Vincent Alexander
Would Consider But Not Likely:
turmoil7
malus
Fat4all
Kopite
Kitsune
Ketkat
Maol
Monkey
Would Not Vote Today:
Gorlak
Fantomas
Fran
****
No one has set off my scum alarm so far, and I don't have enough to make a compelling case on any of my scum reads so far, but right now I'm leaning over a VOTE: Meatwad. He threw out a vote on turmoil after Fantomas "pressured" people to start voting and didn't bother explaining any other read until now after Gorlak prodded him again.
Kalor has this same modus operandi so far as scum or town, but the Meatwad wagon looks more compelling now.
Would Vote Today:
Kalor
Meatwad
Vincent Alexander
Would Consider But Not Likely:
turmoil7
malus
Fat4all
Kopite
Kitsune
Ketkat
Maol
Monkey
Would Not Vote Today:
Gorlak
Fantomas
Fran
****
No one has set off my scum alarm so far, and I don't have enough to make a compelling case on any of my scum reads so far, but right now I'm leaning over a VOTE: Meatwad. He threw out a vote on turmoil after Fantomas "pressured" people to start voting and didn't bother explaining any other read until now after Gorlak prodded him again.
Kalor has this same modus operandi so far as scum or town, but the Meatwad wagon looks more compelling now.
Welp, I'm caught up. My feelings are.....I could land on Turmoil. But I don't know if that is because I really think Turmoil is iffy, or because I'm just chasing a wagon. My early reads are always shit.
I'm not a fan of voting Turmoil at the moment because that train looks strong, and I'd like there to be some competition to drive discussion. Sooo.
VOTE: Meatwad
Turmoil has a vote here also, so should be a fun park to try and get a fire going.
VOTE: Meatwad
Turmoil has a vote here also, so should be a fun park to try and get a fire going.
The train that has three people on it now, one of whom is the person you're now voting?
I just want to state for the record that I've been doing would/would not vote lists since Fanto was in short pants, goddammit.
I assume this has changed since you've scattered your vote everywhere, including among these players?
The world is a shit place and getting shittier. Hope you feel a little better later though, regardless.
Did you had a previous read on Meatwad and turmoil? There are a lot of disclaimers on both posts and it looks like you're not putting your foot down in either read.
Try and take it easy on yourself Ket. Hope you can come back and play with us if you feel better later.
OP
OP
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start
Meatwad (3 votes)
Fantomas - #123 #168
Fran - #321
turmoil7 - #323 #371
Fandorin - #364
Vincent Alexander - #367
turmoil7 (3 votes)
Gorlak - #108
Fantomas - #187 #317
Meatwad - #213
Dr. Monkey - #274 #363
Kalor - #280
Vincent Alexander (2 votes)
Dr. Monkey - #363
turmoil7 - #371
Fat4all (1 votes)
turmoil7 - #130 #205
Ketkat - #169 #373
Kopite - #272
Gorlak (1 votes)
Kitsunelaine - #109
Fantomas - #168 #187
Kalor (1 votes)
Fantomas - #317
turmoil7 - #322 #323
Ketkat (1 votes)
Maolfunction - #209
Maolfunction (1 votes)
turmoil7 - #205 #293
malus - #295
Kopite (0 votes)
turmoil7 - #50 #82
Fran (0 votes)
Kitsunelaine - #80 #109
Dr. Monkey (0 votes)
Fantomas - #52 #123
turmoil7 - #293 #322
Not voting: Fat4all, Ketkat
Post Counts:
Fantomas: 49 Dr. Monkey: 42 turmoil7: 36 Fandorin: 33 Gorlak: 28 Kitsunelaine: 26 Kopite: 18 Fran: 17 Fat4all: 16 Maolfunction: 16 Meatwad: 14 Vincent Alexander: 10 Ketkat: 9 malus: 7 Kalor: 5
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Day Start
Meatwad (3 votes)
Fran - #321
Fandorin - #364
Vincent Alexander - #367
turmoil7 (3 votes)
Gorlak - #108
Meatwad - #213
Kalor - #280
Vincent Alexander (2 votes)
Dr. Monkey - #363
turmoil7 - #371
Fat4all (1 votes)
Kopite - #272
Gorlak (1 votes)
Kitsunelaine - #109
Kalor (1 votes)
Fantomas - #317
Ketkat (1 votes)
Maolfunction - #209
Maolfunction (1 votes)
malus - #295
Kopite (0 votes)
Fran (0 votes)
Dr. Monkey (0 votes)
Not voting: Fat4all, Ketkat
Post Counts:
Fantomas: 49 Dr. Monkey: 42 turmoil7: 36 Fandorin: 33 Gorlak: 28 Kitsunelaine: 26 Kopite: 18 Fran: 17 Fat4all: 16 Maolfunction: 16 Meatwad: 14 Vincent Alexander: 10 Ketkat: 9 malus: 7 Kalor: 5
Current Countdown:
Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
I don't think Meatwad is the right lynch here. Feels like scared town. People were ignoring him until I mentioned him being a low hanging fruit. Fran got the ball rolling in #320/21, which is giving me pause about him (fran) at least something to note later. Who has played with Meatwad before? Fantomas you're always a sucker for meta.
Vincent though, let's see how things develop.
Vincent though, let's see how things develop.
More or less, I didn't have a strong opinion before nor do I do now, and I am not really in a position rn where I can say I won't vote one of them if it comes to it
From want to lunch more to less, I would go: Malus(too set on me and maol), Kalor, VA, Kopite
I think Kopite has some bursts of activity here and there so I feel a little better about him
Sure. I don't feel strongly on my town lean on her either, but that's my reasoning for it.
I wouldn't vote Meatwad. If Meatie is scum it'll come out; with this group I don't think he could hide for too long. Too many sharp eyes here.
So since you scumread me, you're saying that I would start a train on my scummate with the votes as they were?
Just getting caught up now on break. Still fine with my vote for now.
This is true, I stole it from Monkey lol.
As others have said, I hope you feel better soon. <3
Meatwad actually feels fine for now to me reading his recent posts, I know i said I'd vote him today, but I might back off that idea now.
Can you point me to this? I thought his vote on Maol and read on you were fairly non committal.
You don't think the same applies to Vincent?
I know you're asking Monkey, but I would say the same does apply to Vincent. I'll be keeping an eye on him, my meta there is strong, if hes not Town I'll figure it out soon enough.
Honestly, when I voted, I didn't realize Turmoil was down to 3. But still, when they were at 4, they were already at 50% majority for the day. I just wanted a vote somewhere not Turmoil.
Meatwad? 0 read. Turmoil? Not much more, but something in me gut. The Turmoil post that made my ears go up a bit was the post about "Sooo....where is everyone else voting today?" (Paraphrasing). Gave me the vibe of scum playing the town role of trying to be helpful, get discussion going, etc.
I caught up on the thread when I could on my breaks, I didn't not show up. I'm on my way home so I'll be more active later.
Welp, enough folks came out and said this isn't a good spot for a vote, so let me rip this right outta here . . .
UNVOTE
UNVOTE
Spoiler so folks aren't subjugated to an endlessly repeating GIF.
Nope. As I said earlier, VA had a bad entrance and then poofed and that's a classic scum move. Also some inconsistencies I don't love there. My vote today will be between him and turmoil unless something changes. Meatie, on the other hand, just flailed a little but also stayed in thread. There's scum Meat meta to compare to AND it felt less agenda-driven than some others.
I appreciate you even when you're scummy.Welp, enough folks came out and said this isn't a good spot for a vote, so let me rip this right outta here . . .
UNVOTE
Spoiler so folks aren't subjugated to an endlessly repeating GIF.
And my hot take for the day is that Fran's relative low key presence feels bad but not bad enough to vote d1.
Being inconsistent is the most consistent thing I do! But I understand the vote. My productivity is pretty terrible day 1, so I mostly try to skate by and pray no one minds me. Much easier to do in larger games. Not so much in this one.
I kinda agree with this read on me. I know that I have pretty mild this day, mostly because almost nothing is going on. There is nothing much to talk and I'm trying to create some content but I know that I'm not prodding enought.
Can you explain this one? Because there is nothing that makes me think that Kopite could be a town lean.
My vote was obviously a prod vote because his low activity. He claimed that he was around and checking the thread but just not posting so maybe a vote would help him participate. And it kinda did because he made a couple of post with some thoughts behind them.
Right now I'm between Turmoil and VA. That vote/unvote on Meatwad seems like a player trying to jump on a wagon and then being worried when people started to call him out.
...
Let me get this straight. You're unvoting from Meatwad after going there with admittedly 0 reasoning other than the fact that you didn't want to vote for turmoil (who seems to be your only scum read/lean right now, because the wagon got some heat?
Who are you going for now then?!
Fantomas I hope you're right on that meta read of yours.
I need Rac to mentor me in the ways of being low-key and not providing reads without drawing attention.
I mentioned that I wanted to drive discussion, and discussion was had! Very useful for a player like me who is not good at day 1 reads. But as I also mentioned, 0 read on Meatwad. No chance I was going to keep a vote there. If I really wanted to hop on a wagon, I'd have slapped myself down on Turmoil.
About this: I'm on vacations this week and I fucked up and bought Civ 6 yesterday, which means that I will have no social life for the remaining of the week.
It seems that she is no longer banned. At least she isn't now. Maybe you should check with a mod before replacing her.