A deadly combination.
It seems impossible for Left-wing parties to combat this shit.
that's all part of the plan,
ruin the education system, fill the land with "poorly educated", pump the info on Facebook , deny science, promiss a 0.01% tax cut for peanuts,
All they care is that they got the idea out there before having to pull it, because no one remembers the retractions. And seemingly no one is willing to punish!
i do think the liberals failed miserably in the messaging of the carbon tax. Like, people would be fucking thrilled to know they got more money back on their tax returns than they're spending...but no one seems to know they were connected.
Can you list the ways that the Liberals are trying to help people in AB/SK compared to the CPC, in respect to protecting jobs that would be lost by moving away from oil and natural gas? Because that's the issue. And yes, people are selfish for voting for their jobs/families over the population 30-100 years from now. But they can't be blamed for that. People in Toronto would vote against climate plans too if it meant elimination of say, the financial industry and retail jobs.
Also that's a good sample size for a regional poll. It's actually not even bad for a national poll. That's what margins of error are for, and indicate.
The CPC policy of oil forever isn't gonna prepare them for that future.
The ABNDP was never expected to win the 2019 provincial election in the first place. Also, the fact they did not get wiped off the map makes it more likely that Albertans will vote for the ABNDP post-Notley.Rachel Notley did everything in her power to help this stupid province, and they turned around and voted for the party who wrecked everything in the first place. Federal left and centre left parties need to ignore us, and drag AB and SASK kicking and screaming. There's no other way. Appealing to them is a lost cause, and you only piss off everyone else by doing so.
Hopefully we can elect someone to help fix our electoral system so that issues like split votes among the left are a thing of the past. I hate that I'm going to have to vote Liberal when my heart's with NDP right now.Yeah the NDP only ever had a chance because the right was totally split. It's the same reason why the CPC can win in Canada: The left if split. If the LPC and NDP were a single party, they would dominate. Well, only for a while because the CPC would shift left to take some of the moderate votes, which would still be a good thing!
The ABNDP was never expected to win the 2019 provincial election in the first place. Also, the fact they did not get wiped off the map makes it more likely that Albertans will vote for the ABNDP post-Notley.
It is more arguable a rightward turn for a combined "left" party would happen rather than a leftward turn for combined right parties. See down south, formation of new labour in the UK, and etc. Even the leftward turn of combined left wing parties in the Anglo sphere seem more like returns to old left values.Yeah the NDP only ever had a chance because the right was totally split. It's the same reason why the CPC can win in Canada: The left if split. If the LPC and NDP were a single party, they would dominate. Well, only for a while because the CPC would shift left to take some of the moderate votes, which would still be a good thing!
Unless UPC splits, I think pigs will fly before the NDP ever wins again.
Alberta had what 30 years of conservative rule, and 30 years of the social credit party?
The ABNDP was never expected to win the 2019 provincial election in the first place. Also, the fact they did not get wiped off the map makes it more likely that Albertans will vote for the ABNDP post-Notley.
I guess I'm not the only one feeling that the Liberal pitch so far is a bit uhh less bold than last time.
AB and SK voters don't care about Quebec voters and what they like. They see a party that wants to bankrupt their economies.I'll cool it. :) It's very exciting.
The wait for Alberta and Sask voters put 2 and 2 together about out why the Greens are becoming so popular in Quebec with Bloc voters is excruciating.
Basically this.I mean, the Green Party would effectively kill the economies of those two provinces...I think it's pretty easy to see why voters would not be behind them. It would be like if a party wanted to do some good things but said to Quebec "but you need to stop speaking French and assimilate."
"Not too bad". You're from BC, aren't you? What do you know about how bad things maybe are or aren't in SK and AB?Not so sure that is the case. I mean the pipeline isn't build and while things are a bit rough that is where they're at and it's still not too bad. Why not start winding things down now and redirect investment and energy sector?
He's spent the political capital. Work hasn't ramped up on that line yet. Believe it or not Liberals got votes from pipeliners last time around, obviously not as many as CPC did, but pipeliners work transient jobs and come from plenty of provinces. I see plates from almost every province in the yard everyday.Nope, I can't accept that argument. Trudeau spent a lot of political capital buying the TMX pipeline for Alberta, he lost some support to the Greens/NDP and damaged his environmental credibility, and for that he was rewarded with 7% support in the Prairies
Those people don't want to be helped
Because LPC is a business oriented party that wants money and a big tent. Notley got fucked by a united right, same way the SK NDP did.Why should any future LPC government help them, when it burns political capital & they still won't vote for you.
Rachel Notley went against her BC and Federal NDP allies for AB, and was rewarded with a UCP majority that will undo her work.
West is a lost cause in my eyes.
I don't know much about the rig work side of O&G but pipeline work for guys in the field is either heavy equipment operating, or labouring. Nobody cares about what they're labouring on for a job, or what industry they're operating equipment in; they care that they have a weekly income of $2700-4400. "Retrain" them in another industry where they'll clear 5 figures a month and faces won't be so long.And how do you ask a 50-something person to retrain into a completely different field?
There are a lot of social and human factors in play here...
It's a lot like Alberta where I am in BC; resource jobs faltering, "economic anxiety", and a heaping helping of anti-immigrant rhetoric.
Yeah, fuck those people. Acknowledging them gets in the way of painting with broad strokes.That, and just fuck everyone in the west who want progressive policies I guess.
Absolutely, a good friend of mine is married to a teacher and they are nervous as hell. Not to mention his policy of paying out banked OT as regular time among myriad other shit policies. At least that asshole already has an RCMP investigation into his antics.Kenney's education plan will follow fordnation. Everybody knows.
Considering only Tories and Grits have ever been in power...I doubt it. Electoral reform condemn the CPC to minority status forever, which means they won't make the change, while LPC is happy being Canada's "natural governing party". Party over country every time, as evidenced by what I consider the worst broken promise of Trudeau's mandate.Hopefully we can elect someone to help fix our electoral system so that issues like split votes among the left are a thing of the past. I hate that I'm going to have to vote Liberal when my heart's with NDP right now.
Why would it be? It was part of the 2015 one, which means it's already been taken care of, right?Electoral Reform is not part of the 2019 campaign, get over it
Why would it be? It was part of the 2015 one, which means it's already been taken care of, right
No.Electoral Reform is not part of the 2019 campaign, get over it
The Charter is turning out to be a useless piece of paper.notwithstanding is on the clock in SK with Catholic schools and public.
Far too many for my liking.Something tells me Trudeau's own party would vote against it even if he was for it.
I always wonder how many Blue Liberals are still in the LPC.
That's where they have to take a breath and see that bankrupting their economies isn't the plan. lolAB and SK voters don't care about Quebec voters and what they like. They see a party that wants to bankrupt their economies.
I live in BC although I have worked in AB in O&G, lived in Calgary during the heady years between 88-92, and transitioned on my own to other work on my own in my mid twenties."Not too bad". You're from BC, aren't you? What do you know about how bad things maybe are or aren't in SK and AB?
A live Q&A talking climate change with Andrew Leach and EcoFiscal guy.
It's not that people "don't want to be helped", it's that suggestions for "retraining" for a "normal job" when out here you're working 40 regular, 35-50 OT paid weekly and get paid LOA or a camp bonus, some 40 hour a week job sounds a lot like "fuck you" to most people out here.
...
I don't know much about the rig work side of O&G but pipeline work for guys in the field is either heavy equipment operating, or labouring. Nobody cares about what they're labouring on for a job, or what industry they're operating equipment in; they care that they have a weekly income of $2700-4400. "Retrain" them in another industry where they'll clear 5 figures a month and faces won't be so long.
It's a lot like Alberta where I am in BC; resource jobs faltering, "economic anxiety", and a heaping helping of anti-immigrant rhetoric.
I remember looking into it and it seems to be able to be used on the actual important parts (sections 7 to 15) that have been used for social rights like marriage equality, which is pretty big.That's hyperbolic. The NWC can only be used for certain sections of the charter, and none affecting basic human rights.
Yes, the gutter version of on topic; "Natural Governing Party" chanted ad nauseum when the day's polling numbers are looking up for the good guys.
If you think May's "carbon neutral" plan doesn't come at the expense of a lot of prairie people's livelihoods I don't know what to tell you.That's where they have to take a breath and see that bankrupting their economies isn't the plan. lol
I live in BC although I have worked in AB in O&G, lived in Calgary during the heady years between 88-92, and transitioned on my own to other work on my own in my mid twenties.
There were crumbling old towns then just like there are crumbling old towns now.
O&G passes through and throws a few bucks their way as they tear things up in town.
Nothing has really gotten better when O&G is let to run amok. Money is just pissed away on extravagance.
Those thick wages might stick around awhile and might transition very well across sectors. It's AB and Canada. Really. First world nation. Super super super rich. Good trade negotiations. Still will have some level of extravagance compared to every else pretty much.
Check out the video here and tell me if any of this makes sense to you in regards to AB concerns.
Exactly. I worked a decade in Edmonton in commercial and residential construction. It's a livable wage and it's above the average Canadian income. I was able to put a down payment down and build a house, which is increasingly difficult these days. O&G is just ridiculous money comparatively though.Yeah absolutely. I mean there's heaps of work for trades in Vancouver, (in the near term we need to build two new Fraser river crossings, a subway to UBC and probably a new gondola too, and on top of all that there's a housing shortage so tons of need for new housing), BUT working in Metro Vancouver with the extra expenses that go hand in hand with that results in 'merely' having an upper middle class lifestyle. You don't get the two car garage with the big truck, and the boat, and the atvs etc.
Let's be honest nothing is gonna replace the gravy train that is oil sands development.
Pretty much. The rural economy took a dump in the 90s with the structural collapse of the pulp and paper industry (when's the last time you used a phone book?) and has never really recovered. Neither BC Liberal nor BC NDP government has figured out how to really fix this core systemic problem.
That guy is such a scumbag.LOL Peter MacKay talking on CTV trying to spin the polls (because they're not going the way Peter wants them to be)
LOL Peter MacKay talking on CTV trying to spin the polls (because they're not going the way Peter wants them to be)
He's responsible for the PC capitulation to let the Reform-Alliance eat it up to form the CPC
There are probably a few blue Liberals thanks to that douchebag but at this point I'd guess they only serve to try to anchor the party to centre rather than get truly progressive.He's responsible for the PC capitulation to let the Reform-Alliance eat it up to form the CPC
Joe Clark will never forget nor forgive Peter
When both parties cater to corporations, it really doesn't matter who you vote for at that point if you're a "Blue Liberal" or a "Red Tory". It just changes the name you write on the donation checque.There are probably a few blue Liberals thanks to that douchebag but at this point I'd guess they only serve to try to anchor the party to centre rather than get truly progressive.
If you think May's "carbon neutral" plan doesn't come at the expense of a lot of prairie people's livelihoods I don't know what to tell you.
What sectors pay that much overtime and live out? Live out is the main gravy train. I don't intend to stay in O&G longterm, there are significant amounts of people like me who are in it for a few years to get a significant amount of money saved and invested. There are savers out here, not just spenders who are addicted to toys. Like I said in my previous post, if the wages stay similar the workers will transition to basically anything. Equipment operators can't transition to forestry currently, and wages for development of cities and highways doesn't involve more overtime hours than regular hours, and being home with your family comes at the expense of your live out. For 15k a month I'll install wind turbines or solar panels or whatever floats your boat, but for all I care I'll hop on TMX for a couple years when it goes.
I like to think I'm left leaning enough to spend time in these threads, and I'm probably the most left leaning pipeliner if anyone I've worked with. I live a minimalistic lifestyle, save and invest money, and see the writing on the wall for these jobs but I also don't expect the guys who spend money like it's going out of style on diesel trucks, fifth wheels, toy haulers, sleds, quads, boats (and far worse things) to wave goodbye to that money instead of go down with the ship kicking and screaming. Coming to terms with the fact that certain lifestyles aren't sustainable is hard for some people to accept.
Thanks for the link to the video, I'll try to watch it when I have better service. Currently I have to wave my phone around a fairly significant amount just to keep up with this thread lol.
Exactly. I worked a decade in Edmonton in commercial and residential construction. It's a livable wage and it's above the average Canadian income. I was able to put a down payment down and build a house, which is increasingly difficult these days. O&G is just ridiculous money comparatively though.
That's progress. :pAB and SK voters don't care about Quebec voters and what they like. They see a party that wants to bankrupt their economies.