They likely didn't count on the NBA story breaking at the same time. I think they underestimated the backlashFair enough they censure him as he did break rules, but it seems they've gone completely over the top, and what did the casters do to deserve getting sacked as well? If that's how they want to act then they're going to have to accept the blow-back. No doubt some arsehole executive has determined the money they'll lose from Western based anger will be far less than what they'd lose in China if they did nothing. Urgh, I would have gone to war for this company at one point in my life, to look at them now makes me so sad.
It's one of those things where you literally can't have it both ways. One country will boycott, the other will ban you outright.I feel like a lot of megacorp will have to take a stance on this in future.
"Are you FOR or are you AGAINST?"
that is actually really cool. Blizzcon is going to be a (deserved) shitshow just when it looked like it could be fantastic (well fantastic compared to last year).
Whats funny about this entire thing is if they didn't take any action this wouldn't even be a story. When you watch the video the guy and commentators were laughing because it was sort of a troll-y comment and now Blizzard turned this into a massive story. What a time we live in.
You grew up and they didn't.It just fucking saddens me how Blizzard of 2019 is so completely unrecognizable from the company who's games I once fell in love with.
If they didn't take any action, there wouldn't be any more Hearthstone in China, or likely any other Blizzard games either if they persisted. Retaliation against Chinese employees, massive layoffs, the entire future of the company in question. That would be a story.
The real alternative was to broadcast themselves that they have no affiliation with the winner nor are the winner's viewpoints or political expressions are representative of Activision Blizzard as a whole and be done with it.If they didn't take any action, there wouldn't be any more Hearthstone in China, or likely any other Blizzard games either if they persisted. Retaliation against Chinese employees, massive layoffs, the entire future of the company in question. That would be a story.
I'm not saying that what they did is right, but I do believe that that's the alternative they were facing down.
Yeah, I'm sure China would immediately cancel all their contracts and ban them for what one player shouted on a broadcast.
/s
The real alternative was to broadcast themselves that they have no affiliation with the winner nor are the winner's viewpoints or political expressions are representative of Activision Blizzard as a whole and be done with it.
The real alternative was to broadcast themselves that they have no affiliation with the winner nor are the winner's viewpoints or political expressions are representative of Activision Blizzard as a whole and be done with it.
China is the ultimate snowflake.Yeah, I'm sure China would immediately cancel all their contracts and ban them for what one player shouted on a broadcast.
/s
Thanks for this response.According to Blizzard's own statement, this is the relevant competition rule.
So the mechanism for punishment (stripping of all prize winnings) was spelled out, but notice the critical point of violation: Blizzard's "sole discretion" that an offence has been committed.
This is the kind of regulation that, on the face of it, looks like it was set up to handle cases of outright abuse, exploitation, and personal misconduct that this very forum often raises a stink about, and which beset a nontrivial number of young, dumb Overwatch professionals in OWL, so I understand. Under most circumstances I think we can agree that some policy that reads like this should be in place. The question is whether applying this rule was proportionate to this incident. Notice, also, that the regulation does not say anything about politics: only offence.
I think we can say quite reasonably that Blizzard's discretion here—using their own regulation to cave to their mainland China crowd, which is cheering their decision on Weibo—was serious error in judgement that is open to disagreement.
That said, Blitzchung knew the risk he was taking and has said he will not be appealing the decision. He's made his point very well and laid Blizzard's complicity bare already, I'd say.
Let's hope that Blizzard doesn't get the same slack that Riot did once the KDA video came out.
...yeah...particularly in this of all issues lolSOmething kind of surreal about a British character being used as an Icon for putting down an oppressive regime. British history and all. Ireland...South Africa..countless others
Let's hope that Blizzard doesn't get the same slack that Riot did once the KDA video came out.
League of Legends music video that came out that became insanely popular.
I mean, the answer will be whichever one doesn't hamper their profits.I feel like a lot of megacorp will have to take a stance on this in future.
"Are you FOR or are you AGAINST?"
It was likely already planned to debut because they had a live performance at a tournament for it too, but it just happened to debut at the right time that the company was swirled in the controversy, so the KDA video took up all the riot games headlines instead of the controversy, helping ease it out of the public consciousness.
Let's hope that Blizzard doesn't get the same slack that Riot did once the KDA video came out.
You forgot Hong Kong.SOmething kind of surreal about a British character being used as an Icon for putting down an oppressive regime. British history and all. Ireland...South Africa..countless others
That was my first guess.
Wow yeah where does Tracer find the time to do it allSOmething kind of surreal about a British character being used as an Icon for putting down an oppressive regime.
Finally, a note on the short time the subreddit was private: For some reason, one of our recent mods set the subreddit to private then deleted his account. It was an odd event, but rest assured, us remaining mods have restored it to public. No, we were not contacted by Blizzard, nor are we employees to any extent. We are committed to supporting this community. Thanks!