-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Best Lightsaber fight scene in the Star Wars movies
- Thread starter Saucycarpdog
- Start date
Maul/Qui-Gon/Obi-Wan for best pure fight choreography/music
Best overall (Thematic relevance, music, choreography, cinematography) gotta go with Throne Room.
Best overall (Thematic relevance, music, choreography, cinematography) gotta go with Throne Room.
I agree with your points about both ESB and RotJ's duels
One of the things that I really like across the two scenes is how in Empire Vader jumps confidently, strikingly towards Luke. In Jedi, Luke kicks Vader ass backwards down the stairs.
I voted "The Throne Room" assuming it meant RotJ and now the option has been amended. This is a worthless poll.
THIS right here is why Empire's duel is the best answer. It's not as flashy as other battles, but it's storytelling in fighting.
Darth Maul fight for the music alone, but the whole thing is brilliant and nearly redeems the whole prequel trilogy. The tension build with the laser gates is inspired and serves as a reminder why Lucas was revered
Burned into my memory
Burned into my memory
This is silly. You'll find problems in basically every action movie ever made if you're going frame by frame.
Episode I. No contest.
My secret fave is Sheev and Yoda though - it's peak Star Wars campy goodness. And Star Wars is always best when they full-on embrace that they are a campy space opera.
My secret fave is Sheev and Yoda though - it's peak Star Wars campy goodness. And Star Wars is always best when they full-on embrace that they are a campy space opera.
Have any of you seen the Throne Room fight? There's a disapperaing lightknife, a guys throwing away his weapon, so he can get killed, a straight kick that throws away 3 guys at the same time and a guy running away from the frame to just come back into it. It's laughably bad.
I watched the film twice, and it wasn't until i saw it slowed down on Twitter that i even noticed the missing weapon. So for me, that doesn't ruin it. It's obviously a stupid thing to do, but at speed i'd never of noticed it.
The Throne Room
No wait,
Phantom Menace
Love that unnecessary spin into an intentional miss.
Last edited:
The missing weapon is one thing, but there's also the spinning attack that goes over Rey's head, the guy running out of frame for no reason and the guy that THROWS HIS WEAPON AWAY WHEN CHARGING SO HE CAN GET CUT DOWN :D
The Darth Maul fight. It helps that Ray Park knows actual martial arts to help with the choreography.
It wasn't enough to save the Phantom Menace from being a terrible movie, but the fight scene by itself is the best of the series.
It wasn't enough to save the Phantom Menace from being a terrible movie, but the fight scene by itself is the best of the series.
You've of course noticed all that on your own during your first watching in the theater.
I love them all even in the films i'm not too fond of (note there is not a single SW film I hate just some are a bit meh)
I wanted to choose Darth Maul vs Obi Wan because it's quite good, but in the end I went Luke vs Vader Obi Wan though I do like Luke vs Vader rotj and the throne room in tlj is great too
I wanted to choose Darth Maul vs Obi Wan because it's quite good, but in the end I went Luke vs Vader Obi Wan though I do like Luke vs Vader rotj and the throne room in tlj is great too
Luke vs Ben is the only that feels a samurai duel imo, reminding me a lot of Obi vs Vader in Episode IV, but this time with some actual cinematography.
Everything else is kinda okay-ish.
Everything else is kinda okay-ish.
Yeah, i'm not dismissing it, because it's a thing. However at first and second watch, at full speed, i never noticed it and the scene still holds its value as a memorable fight for me. You can break anything done to the nth degree and show how fake it is, but sometimes you just gotta enjoy it.
if, at full speed on first watch it was extremely noticeable, then fair enough. but it wasn't.
How the fuck is Luke/Vader - RotJ not a poll option?
It is objectively the best and the only correct answer.
It is objectively the best and the only correct answer.
I voted for Empire Strikes Back only because Return of the Jedi wasn't on the list. The fight in the throne room in ROTJ is the best one. The emotions, the music, the way its shot. Its all great.
Darth Maul fight is neat with how it starts and the force field doors and the incredible music but it's ruined by how the villian is a blank slate devoid of character and how comically bad the fight ends.
Darth Maul fight is neat with how it starts and the force field doors and the incredible music but it's ruined by how the villian is a blank slate devoid of character and how comically bad the fight ends.
I voted for throne thinking it was RoTJ then I see its TLJ. I feel disgusted. Ewwww. This poll is not well setup imo.
Return of the jedi or empire. The story and cinematography in those two fights destroy all the others combined.
Not in terms of choreography, but overall staging and impact, it's gotta be Luke VS Vader in ESB. The progression, the iconic frames and moments, the part when Vader decides to show Luke how outclassed he is by using his crimson saber for dramatic punctuation while he trashes Luke with Force-propelled blunt objects... And that devastating ending, with Luke in extremis, cowering at the edge of oblivion, when Vader drops one of the most memorable bombs in cinema history.
The throne room duel with Luke VS Vader in ROTJ is a close, close second though. Probably equal. A strong case could be made that it's the best. Anyway, the part under the stairway after Vader threatens Leia, when Luke brings the fury while that haunting, unforgettable music plays, is the single most impactful moment from any duel in the entire series. Star Wars is not Star Wars without that perfect scene.
After those two, it's definitely the TLJ throne room scene. The sequels have magnificent lightsaber action. Really great choreography and effects that make lightsabers feel dangerous. And unlike anything in the prequels, the duels speak volumes about each character through their fighting styles.
The throne room duel with Luke VS Vader in ROTJ is a close, close second though. Probably equal. A strong case could be made that it's the best. Anyway, the part under the stairway after Vader threatens Leia, when Luke brings the fury while that haunting, unforgettable music plays, is the single most impactful moment from any duel in the entire series. Star Wars is not Star Wars without that perfect scene.
After those two, it's definitely the TLJ throne room scene. The sequels have magnificent lightsaber action. Really great choreography and effects that make lightsabers feel dangerous. And unlike anything in the prequels, the duels speak volumes about each character through their fighting styles.
Well, both throne room scenes are fantastic. The fact that the Darth Maul fight is getting the most votes is a bit disheartening to me thiough.
Yep, it's like a Disney World lightsaber show. Maybe the fantastic Duel of the Fates music confused people into thinking that fight was good.
Well, that and Maul's cool factor. He is indeed very cool, in a flashy and every so slightly juvenile sort of way. Great character design though. Good job Iain McCaig, Ray Park, and Peter Serafinowicz.
It is kind of telling, isn't it? Casts all the TLJ hate in a new light.
In my old age now, I say Vader and Obi Wan in episode 4. As a younger man I got the most hype out of seeing Count Duku and Yoda.
Also, the Darth Maul fight is unbelievably good still, to this day. Terrible movie, amazing fight scene.
Also, the Darth Maul fight is unbelievably good still, to this day. Terrible movie, amazing fight scene.
