This is my vote too.
YupStrawberry Cheesecake
As a child, I'd melt it and drink it through a straw.
Try the good stuff and it's hard to go back to the cheap slop.
I never get Ben & Jerry's so I wouldn't know. I'm not about to pay over $4 for that small container. $2.50 or under for a 48oz from Wegman's or Turkey Hill.
The correct answer. I could eat this everyday.
I voted for Half Baked, but you reminded me of the true GOAT. Changed my vote
If I haven't found this before I die I'm going to have to have someone pour a melted tub over my coffin as it's lowered.
Of the ones currently available in tubs here, I'd say Phish Food.
You are all people of fine taste who have the correct answer. It is an absolute travesty that it is not a named option in the poll. A TRAVESTY!
Peanut Butter World (it's a Target exclusive for some reason)
The flavors in this are just insane if you like Chocolate, Peanut Butter, and Cookies.
You seriously won't be disappointed. Head to Target! lol, I hate that it's exclusive