Me too. The general negative judgmental reaction here is dumb.I honestly don't see anything wrong with the story. It's not like his daughter was fucking dying from starvation. I found it heartwarming.
this is what people were upset about? this is not a big deal and she is 9 so like what 5th or 6th grade? she could google it.
Hey, how about this shit?I can see why people are upset at his parenting tactics, but some of the takes here attacking him go beyond cringeworthy.
HahahaThis dork sounds like someone who'd narrate his own sex mid coitus.
Lmao. This is exactly why this whole scenario is stupid.When your daughter has never ridden a bike and asks you to show her how...
Yeah, it's dumb to think you have to be a pompous asshole to starve a kid for over six hours to teach her a lesson and then proceed to brag about it online.Me too. The general negative judgmental reaction here is dumb.
Me too. The general negative judgmental reaction here is dumb.
Yup. Spot on. Some in this thread who even agree to this bullshit subscribe to this same mantra. I never expect my kids to have to struggle there are many ways to have them have moments of creativity and learn how to solve things than this. Teaching your child to fish is good watching your child struggle to fish when you can teach them is terrible parenting.Can't believe there's people here on Era defending this guy.
I was taught how to open cans by my parents. You know how long it took? A few mins. They showed me how to do it, then gave me the can and opener to finish it. Done. No need for me to learn to appreciate the physics of can opening or waste six hours of my life.
I like this take on it:
I'd forgotten how finicky the tool really is, particularly when it comes to the puncture. She had it all lined up! But the cutting wheel is a little wobbly (by design) and you have to really get on top of it to clamp it down. You know the feeling? You can misfire the damn thing!
Not all kids are allowed to be that free with tech?Seems like BS because why wouldn't a kid just be able to google it? They're 9, not 4. and you only have canned baked beans in the house? Like what kinda nightmare house are they supposed to be living in?
Who uses a can opener that punctures? Is this a different type or just people who dont know how to use a can opener?
With this hypothetical lack of freedom and given his shitty tweets, I can tell BeanDad would be insufferable to be in the same room with.
Having your kid struggle and have to overcome it is great. Have your kid struggling for SIX HOURS on a can opener means you as a parent have failed to give your child the problem solving skills to figure out something that simple.Yup. Spot on. Some in this thread who even agree to this bullshit subscribe to this same mantra. I never expect my kids to have to struggle there are many ways to have them have moments of creativity and learn how to solve things than this. Teaching your child to fish is good watching your child struggle to fish when you can teach them is terrible parenting.
Yeah I'm Fucking glad you're not a parent.I'm not a parent, but other than the absolutely obnoxious tone of this thread, I don't see an issue with what he did... Teaching things yourself is a good tool to have.
I'm not sure how long they've gone without eating or how hungry she was, but now eating for 6 hours is hardly starving.
of course it bullshits, kid would have thrown the can down and find something else to eat after max 15 mins. It just the self-congratulate, smugness, and masturbate tone of the Twitter thread rub people the wrong way. The guy sounds like an absolute tool, and he posts the retelling story to jack off to internet point, which mind you, how fuck in the head you have to be to be smug about not having a bonding moment with your kid, instead, berate them.Seems like BS because why wouldn't a kid just be able to google it? They're 9, not 4. and you only have canned baked beans in the house? Like what kinda nightmare house are they supposed to be living in?
John Roderick? Like, "thanks to John Roderick of The Long Winters for the use of our theme song 'It's A Departure' off the album 'Putting The Days to Bed'" John Roderick?
Oh I can.
THE FIRST WORDS OF THE FIRST TWEET AT THE BEGINNING OF THE OP BEGIN WITH "my daughter (9) was hungry" AND THEN SHE DIDN'T EAT FOR 6 HOURSI'm not a parent, but other than the absolutely obnoxious tone of this thread, I don't see an issue with what he did... Teaching things yourself is a good tool to have.
I'm not sure how long they've gone without eating or how hungry she was, but now eating for 6 hours is hardly starving.
Who uses a can opener that punctures? Is this a different type or just people who dont know how to use a can opener?
Yeah I've found that parenting techniques is more of a sensitive subject than religion or politics!Not surprised honestly. There have been threads about parents using physical punishment and people have defended it. Even worse is when you have decades of studies and data showing how that and what this guy is doing to his daughter is bad, yet you'll still have people go "I know what's best for my kids".
Yep and the cycle continuesNot surprised honestly. There have been threads about parents using physical punishment and people have defended it. Even worse is when you have decades of studies and data showing how that and what this guy is doing to his daughter is bad, yet you'll still have people go "I know what's best for my kids".
Yup. Spot on. Some in this thread who even agree to this bullshit subscribe to this same mantra. I never expect my kids to have to struggle there are many ways to have them have moments of creativity and learn how to solve things than this. Teaching your child to fish is good watching your child struggle to fish when you can teach them is terrible parenting.
They're good if you're opening something like condensed milk or a thin soup.Who uses a can opener that punctures? Is this a different type or just people who dont know how to use a can opener?
That is textbook abuse and nowadays, punishment by withdrawal of food would be classed by any social services teams as abusive Parenting.Seems like barely anyone in this thread is actually calling it child abuse.
But also, sending a kid to bed without dinner is fucked up. That's a horrible way to punish a kid, and a great way to give them food issues.
Yep it's proven people operate differently when hungry like judges give worse sentences before lunch than after lunch for example, and it's tires the trope about "hard work" when reality is people success is based on people they know, being put in the right situations and having a ton of opportunities to not only succeed but fail without detriment. And spot on about help I STRUGGLE with asking for help at times because some in society makes it seem like it's a bad thing, you could be spending hours upon hours on shit that someone who has experienced x y z could resolve and teach you in that moment and save time.There's really not much difference between the "I'm forcing you to figure out things" and the "pull yourself from your bootstraps" mentalities. The condescending assumption of intellectual lazyness on the part of anyone that's in a less advantageous position from you; the notion that everyone can pull themselves up to your position with just a bit of work and ingenuity. In short, the belief that everything you have, you obtained solely through your own virtue, and so should others. All of this to convert any way of actually helping others, from a moral obligation, to something harmful you should avoid doing for their own good.
There's also, of course, the more direct, obvious similarity of trying to teach others valuable life lessons while they're fucking starving.