• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
  • We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Solo

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
15,756
By giving up the stone he saved the day, we just didn't know it yet.
Regardless, he had a massive role in Infinity War and Endgame, despite only having one solo movie.

Does it feel like unjustified attention?

Strange wasnt out there in the trenches dealing the death blows to Thanos. Timing is key too though - his movie was 1.5 years before IW. CM came out a month before Endgame. Like, there were people sitting in the theater for Endgame who had not seen CM yet (hell, I just did recently) because it was so recent and still in theatres. I wonder what those people must have thought when she shows up for the first time (to them) and eventually factors into the final fight in a large way.

I just feel like either CM should have been released earlier, or be released when it did and not feature her prominently until the next team up movie. I dont care who the character is, showing up to save the day after just being introduced to audiences doesnt sit well with me amidst a 10 year saga.

Her appearance in Act 1 was a perfect intro for the audience not yet familiar with CM, and I think it should have been left like that instead of bringing her back in Act 3.
 

Blader

Member
Oct 27, 2017
26,623
Given how little Carol actually does in Endgame I don't know what the issue is with her role. The most impactful things she does are save Tony and destroy Thanos' ship. She doesn't beat Thanos herself or really do much of anything significant in the battle other than being one of many to keep him from snapping his fingers again. I could see maybe having her role in the final battle replaced with Hulk but I liked it as is. Certainly doesn't hurt for her sequels that she plays a part in what could end up being the biggest movie of all time.

Maybe his part was supposed to be added during reshoot but unfortunately his brother aka writer/director for Kraglin scene got fired.

Gunn was fired after Endgame had already wrapped. In any event, Sean Gunn also plays Rocket on set and I don't see how his brother's firing would suddenly lead to his being blacklisted from the production.
 

LiK

Member
Oct 25, 2017
32,109
I didn't like it when he comes back in hologram form.
Makes me think we are going to have LMD shennanigans

I thought it made sense that he would make a farewell message in hologram form. Gave it some closure. Highly doubt he'll return cuz RDJ is pretty much done with the movies and I'm not sure they would bring him back. Would really ruin his death.
 

Solo

Avenger
Oct 25, 2017
15,756
That is true though that Endgame also has to lay the seeds for the next generation of Avengers (or whatever comes after Avengers) movies, and as such CM playing a larger role than I would have liked does make sense from a forward looking perspective.
 

Book One

Member
Oct 25, 2017
4,823
Has Downey made any comments or done interviews discussing his end with the MCU? I'd be interested in hearing how he reflects on the whole thing, and how he feels about the Stark character arc.
 

Garrett 2U

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
5,511
Strange wasnt out there in the trenches dealing the death blows to Thanos. Timing is key too though - his movie was 1.5 years before IW. CM came out a month before Endgame. Like, there were people sitting in the theater for Endgame who had not seen CM yet (hell, I just did recently) because it was so recent and still in theatres. I wonder what those people must have thought when she shows up for the first time (to them) and eventually factors into the final fight in a large way.

I just feel like either CM should have been released earlier, or be released when it did and not feature her prominently until the next team up movie. I dont care who the character is, showing up to save the day after just being introduced to audiences doesnt sit well with me amidst a 10 year saga.

First, Doctor Strange was one of the stars and main focuses of Infinity War. He was more effective against Thanos as anyone else, other than arguably Iron Man who got a scratch off. He was the only character who gave the audience any hope after Infinity War.
Captain Marvel had three short hero moments in Endgame: she destroyed Thanos' ship, she was 1 out of a handful of people to escort the gauntlet, and she stopped 1 out of the 3 snap attempts.

Second, you're concerned about her exposure to audiences compared to Doctor Strange? Her solo movie has DOUBLE the box office numbers than his movie! He controls time and does space magic, she flies and glows with fire.

Your concern is absurd.
 

Kin5290

Member
Oct 26, 2017
3,390
Basically this. A 'Normal' full strength Thor dual wielding his two weapons would've literally torn Thanos apart.
Honestly think having both weapons was a liability rather than an asset. Thor hasn't exactly trained to use both weapons at once prior to fighting Thanos and he knocked Iron Man out of the three on one fight using both weapons together.
 

Ragnorok64

Banned
Nov 6, 2017
2,955
How would Thor even exercise? Would he have to tow asteroids around or something? Like regular exercise is meaningless to someone with his base strength.
 

Bufbaf

Don't F5!
Member
Oct 25, 2017
12,670
Hamburg, Germany
After a third rewatch, maybe this has been asked already but here goes: How did Clint manage to end up with the soul stone? I know it's "a soul for a soul" and all, but the point is that you yourself have to let go of what's most important to you, and he clearly didn't do that - Natasha and him even fought over who won't have to let go.
Thanos on the other hand threw Gamora himself, he clearly showed the will to go through with it. Shouldn't Skull have been all like "Naw dude, you didn't do shit to earn this thing"?
 

Freddy=Legend

Drive-in Mutant
Member
Oct 29, 2017
5,125
Me too because it felt appropriate for one of the heroes weve grown to love over the past decade to be deeply implicated in taking down Thanos instead of a character we just met.

I think Hulk got his moment to shine when he survived wearing the gauntlet & bringing back half of all life in the universe. He may not have got his hands dirty in a fist fight, but Hulk did one of the most heroic things in the film questioning until the moment he snapped his fingers that even the Gamma in his body might not let him survive using the stones.
 

Neo_MG90

Member
Apr 23, 2018
1,136
Saw the movie last night. I loved it, great ending for this jouney that Marvel started 10 years ago.

The first 2/3 of the movie were a little slow for me, until there I was thinking that IW was better, but the last act with the final battle, holy shit that was amazing.
People here cheered the most when Cap took Mjölnir, but also throught the battle, and the "Avengers, assemble!", oh man

For me it was the perfect ending for Tony, really powerful scene, that got me good, and would have been even better if MY OWN GIRLFRIEND hadn't spoiled that for me, lol. This spoiler was going so rampant that she thought that I knew about that too. I had heard about it, but then she confirmed it. Oh well, it still was great. Gonna watch it again this weekend.

Now I wonder what comes next, who will be the next big villain and if and/or how they are going to introduce the X-Men, Fantastic Four and the rest of the Marvel cast, now that they have all the rights.
 

Lotus

One Winged Slayer
Member
Oct 25, 2017
105,935
After a third rewatch, maybe this has been asked already but here goes: How did Clint manage to end up with the soul stone? I know it's "a soul for a soul" and all, but the point is that you yourself have to let go of what's most important to you, and he clearly didn't do that - Natasha and him even fought over who won't have to let go.
Thanos on the other hand threw Gamora himself, he clearly showed the will to go through with it. Shouldn't Skull have been all like "Naw dude, you didn't do shit to earn this thing"?

He lost someone he loved, he now gets the stone. Simple. That's all that needs to be done, anything else is just making up rules that were never stated.
 

Deleted member 19218

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,323
Heh, it's funny, I remarked back before CM hit how unearned it was going to feel when CM saves the day in Endgame a mere month after being introduced. I got some flak for that, some "settle down, she will barely be in it/barely do anything" responses, and yet.....she kinda did exactly what I feared.

She is supposed to be the strongest though. Also, the post credit scene in Infinity War was kind of set up something special with this character. Until this point, Nick Fury never felt a need to call this character. Only now, it's like losing in Street Fighter or some other fighting game while experimenting as a character but then you pick your main and fight. So it's only expected that she would have a large impact. Nick Fury was pulling out his trap card and it was meant to generate hype.

Did it feel unearned when Doctor Strange saved the day in Infinity War?

I would say he just saved the day across both movies :P
 

brinstar

User requested ban
Member
Oct 25, 2017
10,275
RED SKULL: In order to obtain the stone, you must lose what you love

[looks at Clint]

RED SKULL: oh damn, man. Yeah you good, go ahead. Feel better man.
 

FFNB

Associate Game Designer
Verified
Oct 25, 2017
6,126
Los Angeles, CA
I also love that over the course of the movies and moving to the US and joining the New Avengers Wanda loses her accent but it comes back in emotional moments like "hands off" in Infinity War when Vision is in trouble. it's like how you can tell a southerner is extra pissed because the accent comes out more. made her "you will" line to thanos that much more emotional.

That was a nice touch. I know people bag on her changing accent, but one of my co-workers is from Africa, and he generally has no detectable accent, but as soon as he's drinking or excited, his accent gets really heavy again. For the longest time I had no idea he wasn't American until we were at a party one night and he had a few drinks in him and his natural accent came through.

Having Scarlett Witch's accent come back in that moment was a great little detail. I wonder if it was her or the Russo's or screenwriters that came up with that.
 
Oct 28, 2017
13,691
I think Hulk got his moment to shine when he survived wearing the gauntlet & bringing back half of all life in the universe. He may not have got his hands dirty in a fist fight, but Hulk did one of the most heroic things in the film questioning until the moment he snapped his fingers that even the Gamma in his body might not let him survive using the stones.
That's true. But seeing some payoff to the smack down he received from Thanos in the last movie would have been a nice way to tie back to that movie. That's literally what these movies are all about and constantly strive for. Suggesting that Huk be involved in the struggle against Thanos at the end is just an observation for how that could have been done. I even prefaced my comment before by saying I didn't mind what they did, I just think Hulk being there instead would have improved the scene (for me).
 

Deleted member 2802

Community Resetter
Banned
Oct 25, 2017
33,729
I read a lot and I'm going by the MCU/contract logic over the comics. They would need to use his likeness if they did that.
I'm almost 100% certain Tony Stark comes back in a cameo/hologram/AI/Skrull/timetravel role. If you pay him 10M for a day's work of voicework or casual footage he'll do it.

Likeness makes it even easier. Just use his face/voice over CG/mocap actor and he doesn't even have to come into the studio. Just get a paycheque.
 

Deleted member 19218

User requested account closure
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
4,323
For me it was the perfect ending for Tony, really powerful scene, that got me good, and would have been even better if MY OWN GIRLFRIEND hadn't spoiled that for me, lol. This spoiler was going so rampant that she thought that I knew about that too. I had heard about it, but then she confirmed it. Oh well, it still was great. Gonna watch it again this weekend.

I wonder how surprising his death was though. Like the trailer is making his situation look really bleak, there's news that this is his last Marvel movie...it just seemed so obvious that he was going to have some dramatic exit. I wonder if many people were surprised or just not surprised.
 

Arex

Member
Oct 27, 2017
12,510
Indonesia
Finally got to watch it, loved it.

If anything, I feel Carol should have had more screen time. I was like "That's it?" Wasted chance, but I guess they can't have strongest Avenger saving their asses so she had to be kicked off to other planets (legit reason I know).

The beginning when they cut Thanos' head surprised me lol. My fave moments were the parent talks with Thor and Tony, Capt's "Hail Hydra", Capt using Thor's hammer, Tony's "I'm Ironman", and beer belly Thor haha. I'm sure there are others.
The final big battle, the entrance scene was awesome, but the battle itself was just okay I thought.

Also RDJ kills it with this movie, his meltdown at the beginning and his death at the end were gut wrenching.
 

LiK

Member
Oct 25, 2017
32,109
I'm almost 100% certain Tony Stark comes back in a cameo/hologram/AI/Skrull role. If you pay him 10M for a day's work of voicework or casual footage he'll do it.

Likeness makes it even easier. Just use his face/voice over CG/mocap actor and he doesn't even have to come into the studio. Just get a paycheque.

They could probably just do the thing from the comics where he's a hologram AI thing but I dunno if they're willing to do that. Who knows. If the next phase doesn't do as well without him, they could pay him to do voicework, like you said.
 

MilesQ

Member
Oct 25, 2017
5,490
I also love that over the course of the movies and moving to the US and joining the New Avengers Wanda loses her accent but it comes back in emotional moments like "hands off" in Infinity War when Vision is in trouble. it's like how you can tell a southerner is extra pissed because the accent comes out more. made her "you will" line to thanos that much more emotional.

Speaking of SW, I'm super pumped for her show as we finally got to see her let loose. She damn near wrecked Thanos and forced him to sacrifice his troops to try and stop her.
 

Trup1aya

Literally a train safety expert
Member
Oct 25, 2017
21,390
After a third rewatch, maybe this has been asked already but here goes: How did Clint manage to end up with the soul stone? I know it's "a soul for a soul" and all, but the point is that you yourself have to let go of what's most important to you, and he clearly didn't do that - Natasha and him even fought over who won't have to let go.
Thanos on the other hand threw Gamora himself, he clearly showed the will to go through with it. Shouldn't Skull have been all like "Naw dude, you didn't do shit to earn this thing"?

Iirc The requirement wasn't to murder someone he loved. Someone he loved needed to be sacrificed.
 

LiK

Member
Oct 25, 2017
32,109
It dawned on me that Vision was permanently dead after it ended. Was expecting him to be resurrected in some form.
 

Tedmilk

Avenger
Nov 13, 2017
1,917
Nope. Because if he flashed forward he would be in his new reality not the prime one. They explain this early on.

They return the stones to their proper places at the right moment.

Also they created another rift where loki is now somewhere in the universe with the tesseract.

But yes, because the device on his wrist enables him to return to his own timeline. It's exactly how the other avengers were able to return. They return the stones to their proper places at the right moment, and in the right timelines.

The thing with Loki happened in a different timeline, so it doesn't affect the main timeline at all.

Since my post I've learned the Russo brothers have confirmed what I've said.
 

Eidan

Avenger
Oct 30, 2017
8,578
So what is the general thinking on how 2014 Nebula brought 2014 Thanos to the future? I rewatched the movie last night and still didn't really understand that.
 

kurahador

Member
Oct 28, 2017
17,572
Nope. Because if he flashed forward he would be in his new reality not the prime one. They explain this early on.

They return the stones to their proper places at the right moment.

Also they created another rift where loki is now somewhere in the universe with the tesseract.
Cap have the time travel wristband gps where it stores the future time/space coordinate he came from.
 
Oct 25, 2017
10,326
So what is the general thinking on how 2014 Nebula brought 2014 Thanos to the future? I rewatched the movie last night and still didn't really understand that.

She had the Pym particles and the memory of future Nebula who helped make the machine/ suit that got them there . The shrunk Thanon's ship and navigated the Q realm like the suit was supposed to do.
 

Freddy=Legend

Drive-in Mutant
Member
Oct 29, 2017
5,125
So what is the general thinking on how 2014 Nebula brought 2014 Thanos to the future? I rewatched the movie last night and still didn't really understand that.

I'd say that the Ebony Maw studied the Pym Particles they took off future Nebula & was able to recreate them to travel through the Quantum Realm to the future when 2014 Nebula activated the platform.
 

hikarutilmitt

Member
Dec 16, 2017
11,431
Finally got to watch it, loved it.

If anything, I feel Carol should have had more screen time. I was like "That's it?" Wasted chance, but I guess they can't have strongest Avenger saving their asses so she had to be kicked off to other planets (legit reason I know).

The beginning when they cut Thanos' head surprised me lol. My fave moments were the parent talks with Thor and Tony, Capt's "Hail Hydra", Capt using Thor's hammer, Tony's "I'm Ironman", and beer belly Thor haha. I'm sure there are others.
The final big battle, the entrance scene was awesome, but the battle itself was just okay I thought.

Also RDJ kills it with this movie, his meltdown at the beginning and his death at the end were gut wrenching.
I would personally have liked to see her do more, but given the stakes and powersets they did a good enough job nerfing her and Thor both so that it wouldn't seem quite so ridiculous. Logically there's no reason she couldn't just fly in and crack Thanos in half or any other number of pieces, but doing that is less dramatic and just kind of silly. At least the buildup of her coming back was great, for me.
*shooting stops*
Me: "Here she comes..!"
*cannons point away and start shooting at nothing*
Me: "Here she comes!!"
Rhodey: "I just detected something entering the atmosphere really fast"
Me: "GODDAMMIT I KNOW RHODEY! SHE'S COMING TO SAVE YOUR ASS!"
*cue everything exploding*

Tony's melt down at the beginning was, indeed, excellent. He also looked super weak and frail from clearly not eating or drinking enough and was just mentally drained from the fight and then trying to survive. It's also kind of a shame we didn't get a moment, maybe, between Nebula and Pepper because he's absolutely right. Hell, I was kind of detecting a bit of jealousy from Nebula when she looked at Tony and Pepper hugging when they got back.
 

IcyInferno

Member
Oct 26, 2017
373
So what is the general thinking on how 2014 Nebula brought 2014 Thanos to the future? I rewatched the movie last night and still didn't really understand that.
She gave Thanos a vial of pym particles... probably had Maw make more of them after studying them so they had enough to go around. Thanos has all the 'time' in the world to prepare since Nebulas watch is synced up to return to the right moment then pull them out. So they executed the plan once they had enough pym particles. Thanos got arrogant though thinking about his destiny and being inevitable. He should have spend more time preparing. He rushed his plan which led to his defeat.
 

Veelk

Member
Oct 25, 2017
14,711
EG - I don't particularly remember his role in the final battle after the undusting, but it doesn't really matter because it doesn't support your point anyway. He's there for the whole fight.
His main role is to take on Thanos, which he gets his ass kicked at pretty soundly. He does the 3v1 vs thanos with Cap and Ironman, then he takes out mooks during the charge with after the assembly, then he is part of the sequence that delays Thanos from getting the gauntlet.

Honestly, I know he's not at his best, but as a fan of Thor, it's hard to see him be someone who just doesn't get that many good hits in. Like, I really would ahve liked if that one bit where he his Mjolnir with Stormbreaker like a baseball, it hits Ironman instead, and basically everything they try against him fails. Which wouldn't be SO bad if Captain America didn't then pick up Mjolnir and basically fight way better with it than Thor.
 

kurahador

Member
Oct 28, 2017
17,572
So what is the general thinking on how 2014 Nebula brought 2014 Thanos to the future? I rewatched the movie last night and still didn't really understand that.
Maw reverse engineer it and Nebula opened portal so they can get through to this specific future. If Nebula didn't open the portal, they would've arrived at their future.
 

Dokkaebi G0SU

Member
Nov 2, 2017
5,922
finally watched it yesterday
i shouldn't have hyped myself up for this. i enjoyed it a lot, but i think i need to rewatch it on demand when it comes out. some things probably didnt stick with me and i dont remember some things.

my highlights
- ironman
- Cap
- Cap vs cap
- Cap vs Thanos
- Thor humor
- thanos's power level lol
- spiderman
- ironmans snap/death scene with spiderman
- thors humor lol

dislikes
- rat mvp
- no luis with antman
- brucehulk personality
- gamora's instant change of heart because of a few sentences
- black widow
- war machine's screentime, what are we getting more movies of him with ironwoman now?
- is there ironwoman now?
- wish the battle scene was longer, just a little bit.
- captain marvel is just op. i believe she could have handled thanos and his army by herself. without the stone to punch her, she would have ended him right there.


when it started to get into time travel, idk, that's where it kind of lost me on feeling their struggle.. =/
RDJ was amazing though. big ups on his acting chops in this movie.

amazing glorification of cap, his combo with M was great to watch. however, this just showed me thanos was just beyond any of the avengers in power and was the ultimate badass. buuut, captain marvel is op and the "unexpected" use of the stone to get her off him was meh.

i did not enjoy how some of the children of thanos went out so easy during the battle. like wow, just get stepped on and that's it? and that quick gamora change of heart, idk. that felt way to easy. i was expecting a bit more before she decided to help. but is she dead now? quill going to look for her in the next guardians of the galaxy? I enjoyed the funny stuff from thor though lol.

i realllly didnt care about the extra screentime warmachine got. antman felt forced. The rat though, the real mvp. bruce hulk didnt work for me. but i guess it was meant to be because of the snap he could handle.

the death of black widow for the soulstone didnt make me sad. I didnt know they loved each other, what? lol i guess i missed that in all of the movies. Nat just looked like she wanted to die in this movie lol.


after seeing this movie, i can see the next few movies occurring the 5 year time skip with black widow and 'ronin'. i'm excited to see spider man though.
right now with my first watch, great, but i think Ragnarok is still above it as my fav movie so far.
 

TheFuzz

Banned
Oct 25, 2017
1,497
That was a nice touch. I know people bag on her changing accent, but one of my co-workers is from Africa, and he generally has no detectable accent, but as soon as he's drinking or excited, his accent gets really heavy again. For the longest time I had no idea he wasn't American until we were at a party one night and he had a few drinks in him and his natural accent came through.

Having Scarlett Witch's accent come back in that moment was a great little detail. I wonder if it was her or the Russo's or screenwriters that came up with that.

As someone who was critical of her accent going in and out, I can totally buy this and now recant my criticism. It does make sense that when she's super emotional her accent comes back in.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.