Saw this today. Mixed feelings.
The good stuff:
- Consequence. I was afraid that they would search for the time stone, rewind and set everything like it was at the beginning of Infinity War. That 5 years passed, that half the universe returns to life 5 years later, and there are actual Avengers dead (IronMan, Cap, Vision and Black Widow; also Hulk is gone, replaced by green Banner).
- The setup for the next big Avenger movie was neatly done. Loki escaping with the Tesseract sets up a nicely done post apocaliptic parallel universe where Tony, Cap, Black Widow, Hulk, Loki and Vision can live, we will probably see it in a movie where the parallel Earth has a fascistic Shield over it, Tony's idea realized.
- The elevator scene retcon and the Hail Hydra from Captain America was a great moment. When young Cap tells him he can do this all day and Cap rolls his eyes, great scene too.
The bad:
- Why is Gamora alive? So they only need to use some Pym particles and bring Black Widow and Vision back? Gamora should be dead since they are in a timeline where she was traded for the life stone.
- Captain America living a peaceful life in the same universe is breaking the rules set by themselves. That shouldn't be possible.
- Hobo Thor. I get the joke, it was funny, but he should have been put in a diet in the movie... I mean, Thor was without an eye for 5 minutes, magic new eye and done. Also, why was Thor so depressed? Because of the death of Loki? He didn't loose any more than the others, in fact, it was less. He had no reason to be as depressed as he was shown. He managed to build New Asgard, rule his people, etc.
- Captain Marvel, so fucking annoying. Undeserved spotlight. Even Spiderman felt he was too new and out of place in the final battle, but at least they had the decency of using him a little; but Captain Marvel coming out of nowhere kicking everyone's asses felt out of place IMO. I thought they made good use of Black Panther, also a new character, don't remember him using the storing of power and releasing in Infinity War.
- The pacing of the movie was bad IMO, needs editing.
Mixed feelings:
- Tony didn't deserve that ending. The dude basically built the Avengers, paid for suits, costs, buildings, airships, etc. The dude sacrificed so much, he finally found happiness only to be killed after, sacrificing everything. I'm sure it was fucking Joss Whedon behind this shit.
- Captain America got a happy ending, also completely undeserved.
- The behind the scenes from the other movies was fully entertaining, but there was no reason to be so sneaky. They make fun of BTTF and then do the same stuff.
- The girl power team at the final battle. Cringe to the max. I think that scene would have played better if all the girl heroes got there and then Banner/Hulk gets there and felt super uncomfortable and made a joke, that would have been nice IMO.
- Killing Thanos at the beginning felt rushed, don't know how to make that scene better, or even if it was necessary.
- They sent Black Widow and Hawkeye to get the life stone. To an unknown planet, the two that don't have super suits or super powers and don't have experience in space. Feels heavy handed.
- Hulk was severely underused; only served for Comic relief.
Unsolved questions:
- There is a new Spiderman movie coming. Will they aknowledge that the people on the class that weren't killed by Thanos are now 5 years older than the ones that were revived?
- There is a new Black Widow movie coming. The movie established that Natasha was dead dead, so I can only see two possibilities, one is that they revive her with some bullshit method (maybe if you return the life stone, you get the life you gave back?), or maybe this is parallel universe Natasha. Or maybe it's just the origin story, although this would be terrible in all aspects.
- Scott's daughter is big now. So she can be a new Antwoman/wasp. Place your bets on who dies next movie.