ATLANTA (AP) — An Atlanta police officer was fired following the fatal shooting of a black man and another officer was placed on administrative duty, the police department announced early Sunday.
The moves follows the Saturday resignation of Atlanta Police Chief Erika Shields, who stepped down as the Friday night killing of Rayshard Brooks, 27, sparked a new wave of protests in Atlanta after turbulent demonstrations following the death of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis police had simmered down.
The terminated officer was identified as Garrett Rolfe, who was hired in October 2013, and the officer placed on administrative duty is Devin Brosnan, who was hired in September 2018, according to a release from police spokesperson Sgt. John Chafee.
Okay I agree he didn't have to die.
But the whole he didn't have to go to jail for driving drunk is being ridiculous. I've known many people who got DUIS for being in a non moving vehicle drunk. So I'm not gonna call racism on that or say fuck the laws
for standard procedures.
They shouldn't of shot that man but bro made a terrible decision trying to discharge that taser. In the heat of the moment It could easily be mistaken for something else/cause needless escalation. Which happened. I don't think the officer deserveS to be locked up for life but some time behind bars seem justifiable.
??? What police officers have you guys been dealing with? Maybe that's how police act when you're white but as a black man the law is the law. Ain't no get your sister to take you home or second chances. You break a law that can lead to your arrest and you're done. It's shocking seeing so many people say they could've drove him home or called his sister. it's like we're living in two different countries fr."hey call your sister to come pick you up, you're not in a condition to drive. We'll wait her until she gets here"
Thats all that had to be said after he failed the breathalyzer
That may be true. Sadly however as a black man I'm not expecting equal treatment with whites by the cops, it's just facing reality. If I'm in a situation with them I'm gonna do whatever it takes to make them non hostile so I can survive. I'm not gonna be thinking "this isn't fair cause Josh got caught for the same thing ". Obviously it's fucked up but personally I know if I tussled with an officer it'll prolly leave me dead until change comes. Again it's not fair but the reality is we can't do all that fighting white people can do with the police.He was already met with needless escalation. Cops manage to deal with drunken frat boys all the time who are fighting them, without killing them.
Sit down and tell your master to come on out and deal with this.Man this is a tough one....
I think the cops did everything wrong up until he started resisting arrest. After he started resisting arrest, grabbed the taser, and then discharged it , it escalated to the point where the cops could make an argument under the law they were at risk of bodily harm. He also was running with a taser, which he was willing to discharge, so you can't just go "oh well, maybe someone will get it back tomorrow"
The problem was it should have never escalated to that point. Not sure it required a DUI arrest, that was the BIG mistake in all of this. Just send the guy home. Let the man call an Uber or a friend.
I don't think the cops should be charged for murder even though I don't think they needed to shoot him. I think this incident just exposes the serious flaws with just the standard operating procedures of the police where it often encourages escalation. And then once it escalates then yeah force might be justified but it's a false choice because it should never escalate in the first place. There needs to be non-lethal ways to handle this.
That may be true. Sadly however as a black man I'm not expecting equal treatment with whites by the cops, it's just facing reality. If I'm in a situation with them I'm gonna do whatever it takes to make them non hostile so I can survive. I'm not gonna be thinking "this isn't fair cause Josh got caught for the same thing ". Obviously it's fucked up but personally I know if I tussled with an officer it'll prolly leave me dead until change comes. Again it's not fair but the reality is we can't do all that fighting white people can do with the police.
That is true. Honestly I'd be petrified to get locked up in current times. The part about the taster that made it worse imo is that it gave the cop an easy case to win, and white america can use this as fuel as justifiable force by the police. Hence ending in no real change, so I can understand why the wendys was burnt down cause it was the only way the message can be sent. Wow typing this out really put things in perspective tho. Thanks for checking me 🙏And you could still be shot to death while tapdancing (not saying this is what you're doing). Folks are feeling like they've got nothing to lose for good reasons atm. You can be shot doing anything normal. Its coming to a head. I mean I think if you feel your life is forfeit, why not grab the tazer?
Standing up straight, but not too tall, and speaking with a calming voice doesn't seem to be winning any votes these days.
people are saying that because everybody has seen videos of cops giving people rides or making them walk home.??? What police officers have you guys been dealing with? Maybe that's how police act when you're white but as a black man the law is the law. Ain't no get your sister to take you home or second chances. You break a law that can lead to your arrest and you're done. It's shocking seeing so many people say they could've drove him home or called his sister. it's like we're living in two different countries fr.
That is true. Honestly I'd be petrified to get locked up in current times. The part about the taster that made it worse imo is that it gave the cop an easy case to win, and white america can use this as fuel as justifiable force by the police. Hence ending in no real change, so I can understand why the wendys was burnt down cause it was the only way the message can be sent. Wow typing this out really put things in perspective tho. Thanks for checking me 🙏
Confiscate his car keys, send him on his way, and citate later... There was absolutely no reason this needed to end in an immediate arrest, and certainly not in his death.
That's the thing that people need to realize,
It was a taser
It has no ammo after its used once, he was running away and doesn't work if you're not pulling the trigger to shock.
People are trying to make it seem like if this Man wanted to kill the cops, when all he was doing was running away from them.
??? What police officers have you guys been dealing with? Maybe that's how police act when you're white but as a black man the law is the law. Ain't no get your sister to take you home or second chances. You break a law that can lead to your arrest and you're done. It's shocking seeing so many people say they could've drove him home or called his sister. it's like we're living in two different countries fr.
Don't you defend our enemySit down and tell your master to come on out and deal with this.
All the redhats are saying that Rayshard deserved to die. It's been known that white folks can get away with shit that others get killed for. It's so exhausting.
Everybody needs to see that cops are fucks and just because he's black they have to arrest him while if he was white, there would be a higher chance of giving that person off with a warning and even a ride home, fuck..
also-
That's the thing that people need to realize,
It was a taser
It has no ammo after its used once, he was running away and doesn't work if you're not pulling the trigger to shock.
People are trying to make it seem like if this Man wanted to kill the cops, when all he was doing was running away from them.
Some people will look at both videos and still deny there is any systematic racism in place, and continue to chant all lives matter bullshit. They will not admit they have white privilege ever. But hopefully these videos has an impact on some people please 🙏
This punk ass bitch, if cops are scared because tasers can kill, the why the fuck can cops use them on people because they say that they're non lethal.
They can't get an accurate blood alcohol level that will stand up in court if they don't take him to the station or hospital.Confiscate his car keys, send him on his way, and citate later... There was absolutely no reason this needed to end in an immediate arrest, and certainly not in his death.
Is that needed though?They can't get an accurate blood alcohol level that will stand up in court if they don't take him to the station or hospital.
Is that needed though?
If he gets home and sobers up, all is good. No need to pursue further.
no proof of him though, they said that they found him sleeping.Dude was driving while impaired and by doing so he put himself and multiple other people in danger. I don't think the cop was justified in shooting him, but I see absolutely nothing wrong with the arrest.
Sit down and tell your master to come on out and deal with this.
He was parked though and slept before being confronted by the police. In this particular situation, he did not endanger anyone.Dude was driving while impaired and by doing so he put himself and multiple other people in danger. I don't think the cop was justified in shooting him, but I see absolutely nothing wrong with the arrest.
Dude was driving while impaired and by doing so he put himself and multiple other people in danger. I don't think the cop was justified in shooting him, but I see absolutely nothing wrong with the arrest.
How is asking someone to move putting themselves in harms way?
I mean, I can see the logic here that anyone in the US might have a gun. But by that logic, asking someone to move their car isn't putting themselves in danger anymore than working in Wendy's in the first place. It isn't putting themselves in danger anymore than leaving their house.
Yes, there's something off about someone sitting in the drive thru not moving. But it could be many thing--he might have had a heart attack, a stroke. In this case he was inebriated.
The fact that Americans think a car not moving in a drive thru is cause to call the cops is one of the problems with America. The fact that cops respond to such a call ready to draw a taser or firearms is one of the problems with America. If the Wendys employees had done minimal investigation, this would have been avoided. If the cops hadn't put themselves in a position where a citizen can get ahold of one of their weapons, this would not have happened.
He was parked though and slept before being confronted by the police. In this particular situation, he did not endanger anyone.
But yea, if you always want to arrest and escalate, go for it. Then you have those situations all the time and it won't get better.
I think this really shows what is wrong with the police in the US. It's an everlasting cycle of increasing violence and the police is not helping to stop it.
At one point in the questioning, he admitted to driving under the influence of 1.5 margaritas. No idea how drunk he was, but he was still coherent enough to realize that they were trying to trap him with that "Do you refuse to take a breathalyzer test?" question.no proof of him though, they said that they found him sleeping.
This is the problem, and why protests need to continue as you never would have the same situation if Brooks was a white person that was found sleeping in his car.
What is the point of arresting him at this point, instead of just taking his keys and getting his ID for a future court summon or some such? Guy is not a danger, no need to handcuff him.
Because you have to prove his intoxication in court, that is going to require a breathalyzer reading or a blood test.
Totally. He decided to park in the Wendy's drive thru and then get drunk, right?no proof of him though, they said that they found him sleeping.
This is the problem, and why protests need to continue as you never would have the same situation if Brooks was a white person that was found sleeping in his car.
The margin of error on those things is incredibly high. They do it to get a ballpark figure, but need to do a blood test to get a reading that can hold up in court. I think the cop in the video even says something to that effect.He did the breathalyzer already. Got the results. Done. Why arrest him?
Being in a car while drunk is enough to get you a DUI in most places, even if you toss the keys out of the car to sleep. Police need to not murder people for a DUI though, that's the bigger issue obviously.no proof of him though, they said that they found him sleeping.
This is the problem, and why protests need to continue as you never would have the same situation if Brooks was a white person that was found sleeping in his car.
It's irrelevant if he drove there before. In that particular situation at that time he was not endangering anyone. He was sleeping in a car.It's not the Wendy's employees jobs to deal with drunk people. Maybe they did go to the car and see the person in it was asleep and they couldn't wake him up. Do you know that they didn't?
Drunk people are unpredictable, so yes, there is potential of them being in harms way. What's your great suggestion outside of "don't call the cops"?
Don't play the "if "x" would have done "x" this wouldn't have happened" game. It's a bad game and does nothing.
He endangered people by driving there while intoxicated to begin with.
From OP said:Friday, officers responded to a call at 10:33 p.m. about a man sleeping in a parked vehicle in the drive-thru, causing other customers to drive around it, the GBI said in a statement.
Uhh...it absolutely is relevant if he was driving while intoxicated. He doesn't get a free pass for it because he was taking a nap at the time. Driving while drunk endangers lives and is illegal no matter when you do it.It's irrelevant if he drove there before. In that particular situation at that time he was not endangering anyone. He was sleeping in a car.
Also, he was not completely blocking the drive-thru.
So in the end it was a mere inconvenience that caused the death of man. Don't you guys see how fucked up this is? In my opinion it does not even warrant an arrest at all.
Uhh...it absolutely is relevant if he was driving while intoxicated. He doesn't get a free pass for it because he was taking a nap at the time. Driving while drunk is endangers lives and is illegal no matter when you do it.
Do you think he just materialized there out of thin air? He drove to the Wendy's and put other people as well as himself in danger. I know you guys don't like cops around here, but drunk driving is an dangerous act and should not just be dismissed.
"Just because the law says it doesn't make it right." How about anyone who says driving while intoxicated is okay is wrong? It doesn't take a genius to figure out why driving while drunk is incredibly dangerous and life threatening.Yes. In that situation they found him in, it is completely irrelevant if he drove there before or not (it's highly likely he did, but that is not the point). At that time he was not a danger to anyone, so any use of force or violence is completely unnecessary.
All you do with your logic is downplaying the killing of a man who should not have died there. This death is 100% on the police in that situation and no one else.
Just because the law says it doesn't make it right. Sometimes, the best solution is to just let the guy be or help him home instead of arresting him. You can still charge him later, since they had all the info.
It's not that difficult.
"Just because the law says it doesn't make it right." How about anyone who says driving while intoxicated is okay is wrong? It doesn't take a genius to figure out why driving while drunk is incredibly dangerous and life threatening.
He absolutely deserved to be arrested for it. Obviously, obviously, obviously, he should not have been shot over it. But should he have been arrested for DUI? Absolutely 100%. Driving while intoxicated is serious and should be treated as such.