I've been dealing with someone close to me who is in this situation. I'm chalking it up to nerves of starting somewhere new though but maybe someone can give their two cents?
The person is working for a company in healthcare, works in a great location in the city - quiet area, park and lake, great stores around, work-life balance is great, and the health insurance price is amazing too. For just the sake of the discussion, let's say this person earns $59k. She decides she wants to leave because of bad management and a hostile work environment. The position is deals with the same mundane thing over and over in her field.
Another company (a bank) reached out to her, opposite side of the area (commute is zero issue). For the sake of the discussion, the person is offered $71k, but hears that work life balance is mixed (but seems to be less work life balance there) and health insurance is a bit more pricey. The area is not as "beautiful" as the one she is in now, just surrounded by tall buildings in downtown. The position in this one is more varied, and presents opportunities to build her skills even further in the field.
She is now nervous about starting the new place as she has put in her two weeks notice but her current employers (all her managers) beg for her to stay because she's amazing at what she does and if there was anything they can do to convince her to stay (which she made no response) and offered to give her job back if she did not like her new place. Now it just seems everyone has been nice to her and she's noticed a larger sense of community in the workplace (posters and events going on). Also, she loves the building and surrounding area but not the company.
She is second guessing about leaving and nervous about it, but I said it is just her nerves getting to her about being somewhere comfortable vs starting somewhere unknown.
Is she just really nervous and got comfortable with her current situation? I'm at a loss at how to approach to answering this.