The sad thing is that the independent contractor thing in wrestling has been going on for so long and so many wrestlers have tried to fight it.
From Jesse Ventura forward there has always been an attempt to unionize wrestling since the 80s.
The problem is that the indy promotions can't exist with a wrestling union, and the large feds will just fire you if you try to form them.
It creates an unfortunate situation where collective bargaining actually detrimental to your future career. Which is probably why so many workers are against it.
Let's say your just spent 2-4 years in a wrestling school. Spending somewhere between $600-$3000 for that training depending on the school.
Your next task is to get experience working for an Indy promotion. If the next thing you did was join the Wrestler Union, that indy promotion doesn't exist.
So then you go to the TNAs, the MLWs, the NWAs, the AEW's and the Lucha Undergrounds.
And you have a similar problem. While they will be willing to sign you they will want you to keep everything very low impact. Because they can't afford to have you break your neck, your arm, your leg. So you can't do the high impact, innovative things that gets workers noticed.
Then the WWE. With a union in place, where they are paying health care and retirement. They take no risks on in ring work. We are literally back to the carney days of in ring work. No top rope moves, no high flying, no harsh submissions. Nothing that can make the WWE liable for injury.
I am a huge proponent of wrestlers being treated better than independent contractors.
But there are a lot of hurdles to it and a lot of things that will have to change about the business if we do it.
Number one of them being that the WWE cannot be allowed to be the promotion who sets these rules.