It's Thursday. You know what that means. ❤️
Cody just had a better match with Sammy a few weeks ago.
Entire next thread about to be themed on shitting on him I hope he finds some love from the fans in WWE honestly and he won't have to kill himself in ring to do it
There's a lot to unpack with Cody. Was that match with Sammy awesome? Of course it was. But that's a theme with Cody's matches: the gimmick ones like ladders/cage/dog collar/street fight are great. But you can't have those types of matches often and the only good non-gimmick matches he's had that come to mind are vs Dustin, vs Brodie, (squash) and vs Malakai. (squash) Otherwise I don't think it's unreasonable to say that he's consistently outshined by the majority of the roster. (and far behind the batting averages of Kenny and the Bucks) But again, those gimmick matches were all something special and he deserves credit for how much he has sacrificed in them.
But I did state big changes were needed for his character. I wasn't necessarily talking about his ring work. It's more about what he could bring in terms on intrigue to any given segment last night. Insert him into anything on the card and I don't know how you could argue his presence would improve the segment. Thinking about it, Cody had three great feuds: Brodie, Jericho, and MJF. I feel like the first one was most intriguing because Brodie's star just kept climbing. Nobody knew how high his ceiling was. (it was really fucking high) The Jericho feud was mostly entertaining for Jericho's heel work. Cody did fine, but Jericho definitely felt like the bigger star. MJF was far and away Cody's shining moment in AE-Dub. He did an amazing thing putting over MJF as a top heel week after week. MJF did his job perfectly, but I would give Cody credit for putting in the bulk of the work. Unfortunately, the destination wasn't as good as the journey and I'd argue the blowoff underdelivered more than any other match in AE-Dub history. The match had Cody's fingerprints all over it (the "overbooking" he's often criticized for) and probably had a lot to do with the false "MJF can't wrestle" narrative that has followed him around.
But Cody did put over MJF. And he elevated Darby when he dropped the TNT belt to him. And he saved Sammy's TNT run with that ladder match. (I'd assume Cody had nothing to do with Sammy/the belt getting caught up in IC bullshit so extra credit to Cody for stepping up and righting the ship on that one) So Cody has done a good job of raising the stock of the potential future HW champions.
But he has also damaged the stock of ready-made stars of the present. Archer was an undefeated beast who tore through the TNT title tourney only to get geeked out so Cody could be the first champion. Malakai Black came in with a unique look, move set, aura, and looked every bit like someone you send straight to the main event. He squashed Cody as Brodie did before and it was awesome! But then he got stuck in the "Codyverse," (first time I've used that) lost the war, and he still hasn't recovered IMO. Don't get me wrong I LOVE Black and am super into everything he's doing, but he has yet to recapture that aura he had when he came in after losing to Cody. (also, making the feud all about Cody refusing to turn heel did Black no favors) Andrade came in and I don't think it's unfair to say he was underwhelming at first. Then he put in WORK (especially with PAC) and was ascending up the card. For whatever reason, he was sucked into the Codyverse, lost that momentum, and jobbed to Cody when a win could've done so much for him to move up the card. Fortunately talent is winning out for him and he seems to be having a great time with the Darby/Stang stuff so his momentum is still looking good at the moment, but had he won the war with Cody he would look like a much bigger deal right now. It's weird because others can lose to talents like Kenny/Bryan and still feel like they haven't lost any shine, but losing to Cody seems to grind everyone to a halt.
But circling back to having him beat Archer, Cody's TNT title run was a huge boon for the company. It brought in talent like Rickyyyyy(!) and Eddie. (one of the biggest fan favorites in the company right now) From what I understand, Cody deserves a ton of credit for the open challenge. Really good stuff that has had a long term positive impact on the company at large.
So his contributions in front of the camera have been a mixed bag. But as far as we've heard his contributions behind the scenes have been nothing but positive. Personally, I hated seeing that sign on Cody/Brandi's dressing room that said "positive attitudes only." That's toxic af. I can't speak for how everyone would interpret that but I hate it. But again, we haven't heard anything but nice things said about Cody from the locker room. And as bad as some things reported on like personal politics and ego have been, what I find more telling about who Cody is as a person is how he handled Brodie's situation. Nothing of what he has done for that family was put out there by Cody himself. It's all been others revealing how much he was there'd for the Huber family. And with their interactions after the cameras turned off at the Rochester show, it was evident that there's a ton of love there. That's all I need to know about Cody and — taking everything on and off screen into account — he's a net positive for AEW. So yes, I'd rather he stick around even if his absence makes for better television as everything stands right now.
*I fully acknowledge that I'm probably misremembering some things and don't pour over every article that comes out about everything that happens backstage.