why would voters vote for this?
Damn, NY here...that fucking bill passed California? Wtf?
After California passed a law requiring gig workers to be employees (Prop 22 shot down that law), there were people loudly and angrily arguing on this website that this would kill their chance to earn a living as a gig worker. People have trouble realizing their lives could be better.
CA legislature really screwed the pooch with AB5 which, when passed, initially made the vast majority of contract work illegal.
Instead of repealing AB5 and trying again with a more well thought out law, the legislature doubled down on AB5, and then started handing out exemptions to specific industries that lobbied for them.
As an example of how bad it was at first AB5 essentially made freelance writing illegal as passed, and tanked the amount of work writers based in CA got. Companies refused to even take pitches from CA writers because of AB5.
Prop 22 came about in the middle of a lot of AB5 pushback and rode that wave. Now, add the pandemic on top of that, and it allowed the question of "contract work for all or paid work for some" to be part of the voting. Neither AB5 or Prop 22 was good law, but voters were told to choose.
What it does illustrate is how poor job opportunities are for entry level workers. Gig work is bad because the work pie is small and the desire for work is large. There is no constraint on the number of workers, so when there is $1000 of work and 10 workers everyone is well paid. When 100 workers sign up, everyone sits around.
Neither AB5 or Prop 22 fix this. Both are band aids that disguise the underlying systemic issues.
worth noting Prop 22 only shoots it down for rideshare/delivery drivers
Truckers were already exempt from AB5 under a different lawsuit and a temporary injunction.
Also worth noting, in SF (home of Lyft and Uber), the vast majority of taxi drivers are gig workers. This benefits the cab company owners and the City. After AB5 passed, SF made a show of going after Lyft and Uber, but was happy to keep the cab companies operating as-is. Even local government was willing to put their finances first.