Given the timeframe, OP is probably an instructor at the college, not a student.
I'd be extremely surprised if a faculty advisor would ever refer to themselves as being "in charge" of a student club, but I guess it's possible.
Given the timeframe, OP is probably an instructor at the college, not a student.
Get some air fresheners for the room. I went one day to the gaming club at my university to see what it was about. There were rows of tvs and consoles but when I walked in the stench... immediately left.
Is there really a need to combine anime and gaming into one club? When I was in college I was a part of a gaming club, but then the leaders decided to rebrand it as "AniGames" and do a combined anime gaming thing and all it did was just turn off the gamers and we all left. Maybe focus on just the gaming thing and let the anime part go.
What's your day to day like? I see you're trying to do a lot of events, which is fine, but what's the scenario for regular meetings? Do you have an inviting place to meet? Are meetings overly Chuuni?
I see a lot of people running anime clubs like they were Genshiken, which is basically one tv with a laptop and maybe a few game consoles there and people come and play or watch in a cramped room with a bunch of dudes and then they leave, and it's super uninviting.
I would spend 90% of your time and efforts making sure that where you're doing your regular meetings is as comfortable as possible, even if that means changing locations.
Also this. I ran the gaming club in college and basically changed the format to "we're going to have the club meetings in the mess hall during the highest flow of students going to eat, because then we can just have two or three setups running soul calibur or halo or what have you going and if people want to play they can. Nice couches, big screen tv's (that we probably weren't supposed to use but no one cared), food we didn't have to worry about and unlimited transparency. It was pretty successful.
Have you tried anything with cosplay yet? Obviously it can apply to all kind of media, but I feel like it's definitely more popular on the anime side of things.
Also, and I'll mention that I'm very uninformed on cosplay and only have the occasional social media post as my exposure, cosplay seems to be more popular with girls; so I see it helping out with the disparity as well.
Sounds like your events were way too unstructured. Like you had origami and Japanese lesson days but no one to teach it? A good club needs some structure rather than just being a meeting place for people who like the same thing. Especially for a hobby that will tend to draw some people who tend not to be the best socializers when left to themselves.
Also I think you should either have an anime club or a gaming club. Not a combined club. I can tell you that if I was looking for a gaming club and saw Anime/Gaming, I wouldn't go because I wouldn't be interested in the anime side. I'm sure the reverse holds true for a good amount of people too. The dual subject of the club is probably turning away more people that you might realize.
No offense but I think you're kinda off base if you think this is why it failed. Most Americans are gonna see this as super creepy if they've never been exposed to the concept, and even those that have through their interest in anime might not be into it. I mean I did my undergrad overseas so I could be way off base here, but this seems like the type of event that would turn people OFF joining the group rather than the opposite.
Gotta consider the times. Some people in the anime/gaming fandoms are introverts or socially awkward. They may want to join but don't and just end up going home. Just try something more casual, nothing too extravagant/anime-like. A chill place where you can watch anime and play some vidya. Some people like certain things from anime in 2D and only in 2D. Not so much irl.
those ideas in the op sound more like a japan club than gaming & anime.
Advice for Getting more Students to join a Anime/Gaming Club in College
This is going to sound mean, but:
Honestly, if you want the club to grow, you should consider stepping down. You admit you're "an older Millennial" and your "tastes and views on games and Anime are probably vastly different than younger Millennials and Gen Zers"...who are the people going to community colleges. It's a community college club, and you've been "in charge" since 2008? That's twelve years. Why not hand the reins to younger students?
Are you still attending that community college? No shame intended if you are — I'm a returning community college student — but if you aren't, why are you still the one "in charge"? College clubs exist in part so that students can have an opportunity to practice leadership roles.
And I second the suggestion that it probably wasn't the quality of desserts (or the location) that caused your maid café event to be "a bust."
my uni's esports society somehow managed to get ROG to lend them a tour bus filled with gaming PCs, and set it up at the big freshers' fair thing we do at the start of the year. It did gangbusters, apparently.
i should ask how the prez how she pulled that off sometime
From the events you list, it sounds to me like you're club is more about celebrating Japanese culture (probably through a Western lens as well) than anime or gaming. I'm not going to speculate on how a formal declaration of such a club would be received in 2020, but as an outsider that's how it reads to me.
Again as an outsider, if I was looking to join a gaming club and found one advertising with origami night and Japanese lessons I'd be a little confused. Like I think what we now consider "nerd culture" is far different (and more common and accepted) from when I was in college in the early 2000s with otaku culture and stuff.
Then clearly you haven't seen Wednesday's schedule, where we train and sharpen our katanas
This is a good point. I assume they do have something in place, but perhaps maybe the OP can explain whatever the process is and we can try and offer some suggestions.Do you have any sort of welcome or on boarding process for folks who maybe saw an event and stopped by a meeting? From your description of the day to day....It sounds a bit unwelcoming or insular. If I was interested and showed up to find a dark room with folks huddled in front of TVs I'd probably turn around before anyone noticed me.
Lmao
unless things have changed since the mid 2000s with funimation (which was when I was involved with my anime club) they typically are pretty open about licensing movies for non profit events for free.
we held our own little convention and licensed out anime to show which funimation just required us to show all the credits in their entirety.
granted this could easily change since Sony owns Funimation now and Sony was a pain to try to work with back in the day lol.
Sentai would likely be similar.
granted this was all before the digital streaming age.
While we did showings like that we also typically ran fighting tournaments. There are tons of anime fighters, and smash is always a draw.
you can also look into if companies have an anime club thing still
Funimation used to (every month they would send us the first disk of some new releases for us to show)
rightstuff still does have an easy to find one
We also did stuff like got some funding for the club, and then permission to spend that funding on the convention we ran as well as food we sold.
we bought pocky and ramune in bulk and then sold them to people at our screenings at a small mark up.
we then took that money and spent it on building an anime library that our members could rent stuff out from.
but each school will be different with such things.
even if the school itself might not give you funding you could see if you could do something similar with the sale of ramune and pocky. Likely taking the risk of buying the stuff up front with your own money and repaying yourself first with sales and then putting the rest into the club ect. Again schools have different views on such things. I wouldn't be surprised if most of them didn't let you basically become a snack vendor. Our school was really lax with such things and it was just like a $50 license to be able to sell snacks for the year lol.
Go up to random students, ask them if they want to join, and if they say no just hand them flowers and random objects you've found around campus until they agree to join.
Thankfully no one saw the maid because as a woman that's something that would make me never consider joining a club...
As someone who ran an Anime club for many years.
Stick to watching Anime, most people in my 100+ member club didn't attend any of the event days. Best results I had were theme days "Slice of Life day", "Action day", "Mecha Day" etc.
I think if you want to go more broadly Japanese stuff, contact your local Japanese cultural society. Book some people to dress up in traditional Japanese garments and play drums and martial arts demonstrations and stuff in the field or wherever students congregate.
To all the people that are saying step down - might be mistaken, but it sounds like OP is an employee of the school rather than a student. They can't really hand over the reigns unless that person also became employed by the school. I would say maybe elect some sort of staff from the student base that you can offload some of these planning responsibilities to, if they don't already exist. That's how it worked in my old anime/gaming club in college. Of course, if they graduate and there's no one to replace them that's still a problem. I haven't been back to my old college club in over a decade but it sounds like the issue they've been having.
Anyway OP we showed all sorts of movies on the DL, we just didn't advertise them so we didn't need to go through the expense of licensing them, which is indeed cost prohibitive.
What's wrong with saying that?I want us to be able to show movies, it's just a question of how to promote it without having to say "Hey we're watching blank".
We did, and the school took it down because "it has to go through maintenance". So we went to Maintenance and got told, because we don't have windows in the room they can't allow for us to have a larger air freshener in there. The school built the room with windows that do not open for some reason and our heating and AC do not work in the room at all, and we've tried to get it fixed.
I hear you, and believe me I would LOVE to get some stuff in there, but no go save people spraying perfume in there by themselves.
Vast majority of our Gamers are Anime watchers too. They're the ones that wanted it both when the club was first formed. We've talked about rebranding but no one wants the change because they don't want to be just seen as "Just Gamers", they want to show they are more than just one type of group. (We also welcome comics, Kpop, and other pop culture fans as well.) We have magic and D&D players there too.
Day to day follows as such. Early morning a select group of gamers come in and start up with four games, typically it's Smash, a shooter of some sort, Newest thing out (AC, Witcher, Dark souls, the new one from Gearbox that I can't think of at the moment, etc), we may get a fifa or sports game, and either an anime game or fighter. This lasts pretty much all day in rotation, Outside of the room we have people doing magic and yugioh in person or on the computers. Once in a while someone will put on an anime, but that's about it. They leave the room dark because it's easier to play for them in the dark for some reason. Friday's have movies.
We have the game room, which is used by the whole school as it's a public space. No clubs in our school outside of Science has a dedicated room (even then they can't always use it because of classes). We've been asking for a room to ourselves but this has not been going well.
Typically we've tried to have meetings in other rooms but the members do not want to leave the Union because they don't want to leave their games. So we have to have it in there.
Meetings traditionally go, President calls to order, everyone listens for a while, we try to come up with ideas to do as a group, people don't offer much in the way of things to do, (tournament usually comes up), our Officers look to me for ideas, I throw several out there, people seem to like them, some people volunteer things. Meeting ends, and they go right back to their games. It's not like they're not involved it's that people outside the club feel, as you said, uninvited, because a lot of the time the members are focused down on games.
It's kind of like wrangling cats.
I would love to do that, but the Student Commons where we have it doesn't have the set up for anything beyond eating and playing cards since our New President treats our college like it's a freaking High school. The room that would be the best for that is constantly in use for some form of event from our Campus Activity board (Guest speakers that get around a dozen or so people).
Thing is, our club is considered the most interesting by the students, but they're, for some reason, scared of us.
Set your booth up next to the iaido club's, that's what did it for me when I was in college.
As some have said already, I think you should stick to either anime OR gaming as a theme, not both.
"Asian" isn't anime specific, and sounds bad in English if not explained/advertised properly.
No teacher? What?
I think maid cafes are too fetishized to be a good event, anyway.
I also think for an anime club every day would be anime day.
Again, did you have a real teacher? Also, being a college, I'd think anyone who wants to really learn Japanese is going to take actual Japanese classes.
I think you need to drop the gaming or anime to have the club focused, and an anime club needs to make anime more normal seeming, rather than play into anime nerd stereotypes or generic Japanese/Asian activities.
Only two of those things are even related to anime or gaming, and you complain in one about people gaming.
It seems like your club has a major identity crisis in trying to do too many things, and it just looks like Weeaboo Club.
The issue is more on the fact that we have been told to fit in holes that we can't. Because the school is limited with it's cultural studies (only Spanish based) we're the one thing they can point to, to say, "See we do care about other cultures, look at our Anime club here."
I'd love it to simply go back to a social club, but the school is adamant about having an "academic or cultural" aspect to the club. We're trying to refine ourselves.
I think these are really good suggestions but probably slightly more applicable to a university setting where you've got a potential base of students who live on campus or likely very close to it. Something to keep in mind with this is that there are usually limitations with respect to being a community college as most people are commuting some distance so it might be a tough sell to convince people to be active in multiple clubs. Their best bet is likely to get new members who are not devoting time to others currently. I think it's still a great idea to increase the potential base of interested people though.As a club your best resource for this is other clubs. Are you co-hosting events with other clubs? You should be reaching out and trying to arrange relevant viewing parties with the LGBTQ club. If there is a tabletop club you can partner with them and co-host an event with Japanese-themed board games, and so on. These types of events integrate your club in with the campus culture; your club members will meet other people and get to know them. People are waaaay more likely to go to a club where they've already met some of the people and feel like they know them. Plus, all the people you'll meet this way are already in clubs, meaning they're already willing to invest time into exploring that aspect of campus life.
I want you to know that I am dying of laughter here.Then clearly you haven't seen Wednesday's schedule, where we train and sharpen our katanas
You're an advisor, not the President of the club. For my Uni's orgs, we were required to have a Pres, Treasurer, and Secretary, does your club have something similar and if so what are their thoughts all of this (and if not you really should in order to create that type of sustainability over time for students to get involved). Also, honestly from your description the club sounds unfocused as hell. It's a mix of an anime club, gaming club, and Japanese appreciation in a way that seems too muddied.
"there's been a downturn in students that want to join the club since we can't do as many activities as we used to due to Red tape (basically we have to give 3 weeks for larger events before they happen, and 2 weeks for smaller events). "
Stop using your poor planning as an excuse for flagging attendance.
I work at UT Austin and joined the anime club mailing list some time ago but have never actually been to a meeting mostly due to the fact that I carpool with my wife (she also works here) and she has no interest so it's just a tough thing to swing. The bigger issue for me in particular though is the stuff they're showing is frankly just not that exciting. I assume it's due to red tape which is unfortunate because it must really limit the chance for success of this sort of organization. In my ideal world, someone from the club would just be able to sign in to Crunchyroll and show some new stuff, but I guess that must not be allowed because the stuff that they show is always incredibly old. I recently came across some sort of thing online where it showed how much it cost to show a film even for a club on a college campus and it was hundreds of dollars. Here is what was played on Friday:
Schedule for Friday, January 24th
Kare Kano is my all-time favorite anime series and obviously there are some classics in there (Utena, CCS, Kenshin) but sheesh, more than half of these shows are older than the kids in college and the other half are 10+ years old. I can't see how this is going to be a huge draw for the young kids who've now grown up in a world with so much streaming anime and availability.
- Black Butler - Episode #13
- Angel Beats - Episode #1
- Toradora! - Episode #14
- Break: TBA
- Rurouni Kenshin - Episode #11
- His and Her Circumstances- Episode #12
- Card Captor Sakura - Episode #14
- Revolutionary Girl Utena - Episode #14
I did find out that the local branch of my library has an adult anime club of some variety (in addition to their teen/tween) so I think I'll try and go to one of their nights. I wonder if they get more dispensation since they've got the Blu-rays and the like and are a public service.
i think simply having a nice planned out schedule of a wide range of anime to enjoy should entice people to stop by to hang out. if a particular show gets popular enough, just have a day for that show only.
if you really want to integrate gaming, just make sure it is the same people who like anime who are choosing what game to play. don't have a separate contingent of gamers deciding, otherwise you're basically just running 2 clubs
Have you considered the possibility that many students don't really want these combined?
If I would have been interested in meeting other people to play video games with in college (I wasn't, I prefer solo), including anime would have been a major detractor.
...You actually tried doing a maid cafe?? I can't imagine why more women don't join.
I think separating the two makes sense. It's possible that I would have joined a gaming club while I was in college, were one around. I would not have joined a gaming/anime club. The opposite is probably the case for many, as well.
Lot of people hating on the maid cafe, but in the organizations I've been in, maid cafe suggestions have always come from the women.
host events for anime fighting games? if you're getting good tourney attendance but little anime-viewing attendance, that seems like the best way for the members to bring in more students who like anime.
Not really a groups person but I would think a group focused on a specific activity would do best by having events where people are doing that specific activity. Also echoing the sentiment that you're probably losing one group by catering to the other, and specifically I would almost guarantee you're losing gamers due to the anime side's Japanese stuff.
Oh yeah, just to weigh in on the combined clubs: I think it makes sense especially at a community college who maybe has a smaller budget, but when I was in college, there was indeed a separate club for gaming and for anime. I participated in both but I was more involved with the gaming club since my two best friends at FSU were a part of it as well -- we actually met thanks to their hosting a Smash tournament and one of them posting about it on GAF!
Just to follow on to the maid cafe discussion.. I just looked up JACT's web page (the FSU anime club I was in) and they are doing one at FreeCon 16, an anime/gaming con in Tallahassee, and have a practice session tonight from 5-7 PM as well as 3 more scheduled for the next 10 days or so. The advisor for the club is a female Japanese professor (which maybe makes it less "weird" than if the advisor is not one -- not sure if this applies to the OP or not).
They're being very picky about clubs that aren't seen as "academic"
At the end of the day, folks don't want to join an anime club. It's like joining the MCU club: there are fans of the MCU, but they're not going to dedicate actual personal time to being part of it in a somewhat official club-like manner when all they want to do is watch it once in a theatre and wait for the next.
No ramifications to add more than just anime. You gotta do it like what werezompire said: make it into a bigger group that has more than just anime.What would be the ramifications of forming it into a gaming only group? Since most of the members for anime are aging out maybe use this as a way to transform the club into something that is more resonating with the student body.
If there is interest in other media then you can still have those events but not limit to anime only then.
Do you have any sort of welcome or on boarding process for folks who maybe saw an event and stopped by a meeting? From your description of the day to day....It sounds a bit unwelcoming or insular. If I was interested and showed up to find a dark room with folks huddled in front of TVs I'd probably turn around before anyone noticed me.
This is a good point. I assume they do have something in place, but perhaps maybe the OP can explain whatever the process is and we can try and offer some suggestions.
Is there like a dedicated sign up table or something? What is your web presence like? Some photos from the events can always help.
I was going to ask if it was ok to just show whatever anime you had on hand to a bunch of people in a school sponsored event, or if you needed permission from the licenseholders to do so? But it sounds like you do need permission.
My college's anime club curate through a list of anime. They start with a list of things people might have seen or mostly haven't seen. Watch three episodes and asks the group what anime they want to continue watching for that semester. As well as taking suggestions during the first meeting and adding suggestions in the second week for vote.
Then they just watch anime every week with a group of people.
They even hosted a Convention one year and it was a great success. They wanted to build off it but the school canned it because the other campus was upset they didn't get to host the convention, and there isn't a anime club at the other campus. But all the money went to club members to attend the big anime convention for a three day trip that drove to and back to the convention each day.
But your club sounds like Japan Club with a western view on it. I feel like you'll benefit more from just watching anime, serving free food for the first few meetings. Then letting members take leadership roles in planning at least one big event and two to three smaller events.
Things you could do:
Host your own anime convention. (Can be expensive and hard)
Pocky Day (Get in contact with Pocky of America to provide photos and maybe get free sweets out of it).
Host non-gaming tournaments. Basically just anime themed competitions in a race to complete them. (Whoever builds this very basic gundam first wins. Or find out who's your senpai based on these clues).
Wacky late night Japanese TV show contests (look up stuff online and see what weird shit the school would be okay with)
Road Rally (You get in a car trying to complete all the tasks with a number value to it between 1-3. With an additional points for being first to finish. Then you grade them and determine the winner. You can have them go to a convention and do it).
Instead of classes teaching you how to make food. Actually use club funds to buy the food and offer people the chance to put together their own sushi and eat it.
We can view the shows if it's just someone putting it on, but we can't promote it without licensing. Our school refuses to allow us to have a cabinet in the room because it's a "Public" room and can't be locked up. Because other students have to be able to have access to anything in the room. That includes any dvds or series that we bring in to play. So students don't feel comfortable bringing in their series and leaving it there when it's not going to be locked up safely.
On my phone now so I have to aanswer questions one at a time. The issue is two things, first is that in order to create flyers we need to have the okay to lisence the show. Two is the fact that we can't promote were watching a show in the school without that license and If we didnt pay for it the school cant put up the flyers so we can't promote what were watching.
And if we put slice of life or whatever on the flyer the marketing nteam we have to get it okayed through gets annoyed for some reason.
Based off this description, it sounds more like people just want a space to play video games, and less that they want to watch anime together. Having the lights off, and no one making an effort in making suggestions during the meetings, plus describing running the meetings as "wrangling cats," does not sound inviting at all. If I was a student interested in the club, all that would turn me off, so maybe work on those things. Keeping the lights on, restricting single player games and only doing MP, and showing more anime (Ghibli movies would be appealing for anime fans of all walks).
Edit- whoops, saw the Ghibli trademark issue in the OP. Guess that's out. But how about Your Name, or other popular movies?
Wait, it's anime, video games, and Korean dramas now? I don't see how you'd get a consensus on anything as far as activities go.
Happened to me at a con once, lmaoGet some air fresheners for the room. I went one day to the gaming club at my university to see what it was about. There were rows of tvs and consoles but when I walked in the stench... immediately left.