There is no "2nd tier" when there are none, and the crux of my initial post is that I certainly don't need a non-black person telling me how little they care about the few black characters they see in video games, when it means way more to me to see those characters at all. You and I ranking their importance/stature and others doing it comes with completely different context and hits way differently.
This summer, my 9 year old nephew came from out of town, for the first time, to spend his entire break with me. Beside it being awesome, two moments stuck out and still swim through my mind:
#1 - He comes in my room while I'm working (I work from home) and asks if he can ask me a question.
"Sure", I reply, not looking away from my laptop.
"Uncle KJack, why are the villains in anime always Black or dark-skinned?"
I literally almost had a fall out of my chair moment.
"You notice that stuff?!", I asked him.
"Yes, it always seems to be like that in everything I watch."
I've been making a concerted effort to make sure he knows I care about his feelings, so I asked him, "And how does that make you feel?"
"I don't know", he says, his default in difficult situations.
"Take a moment and think about it", I counter, not letting him off the hook.
He comes back pretty quickly, "It makes me really maaaad."
I softly pressed him to go deeper on the "why" but he couldn't articulate it.
#2 - This one is short. I come out of my room and my nephew is using the TV in my lounge area to watch Raising Dion on Netflix.
He pauses it and asks me: "Uncle KJack, why do I like, get into shows better when they have Black people?"
"Because it helps you relate to the character's better."
He looks at me kinda confused and says, "But I don't have superpowers, I can't relate..."
I fix it with, "Yeah but it's easier for you to put yourself in his shoes when he looks like you, dresses like you, talks like you, and likes the same things we do in our culture."
So my thing is, if a 9-year old is this tapped into how we are represented and can voice being emotionally affected by it, who has the right to tell anyone how to feel about Smash Bros passing up people that look like them after nearly 100 chances to throw a bone? It's not that Smash is being focused on to the detriment of other examples, it's that we've never seen such an egregiously exclusionary tale in modern fighting games.