-
Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.
-
We have made minor adjustments to how the search bar works on ResetEra. You can read about the changes here.
B/S/T Feedback Thread | Read the OP Please
- Thread starter Cloggerdude
- Start date
Positive human feedback for Birbo
He sent me a Vudu code for free. Please send good vibes and karma their way.
He sent me a Vudu code for free. Please send good vibes and karma their way.
I sent a PM about the same code soon after he posted but never received a reply about it. I hate when people don't bother to PM back.
What did battousai do to deserve neutral feedback? He paid for an item you didn't deliver. If anything, he deserves positive feedback, or just nothing at all.
I refunded him very quickly... it was $7. If he deserves nothing at all, than so believe I do too. As I said above, essentially nothing happened when it came down to it.
I don't think you understand what you did.
Our transaction was done the moment you sent me the code at 5:03AM EST. It doesn't matter that I didn't redeem the code immediately; In fact, I send you a PM after receiving the code that I wouldn't be able to redeem the code until after work.
Once our transaction was done, the other person PM'ed you back, and then paid you. You then sent them the exact same code that you sent me, which they redeemed soon thereafter.
After the other user redeemed the code, you sent me a PM at 1:04PM EST
EIGHT HOURS after I had the code in my possession.
Just because I hadn't redeemed it, it doesn't mean that you can sell it again. We had agreed on the terms of the sale, exchanged goods and the sale was completed. That code, for all intents and purposes, was mine. Whether I redeemed it when I got it or a year from then, it shouldn't have made a difference.
Problem being, he had it in his possession first - I just hadn't received payment and gotten cold feet, for all I knew it was still available and I was trying to pass it to next person - should I have made the pretenses clearer? Yes, I should have, but the fact nobody lost anything here I'm standing by my neutral feedback. Got afraid, tried to help, I just wish I didn't sell the fucking thing at all.
That's not what you told me via PM.
battousai said:
chronic_archaic said:
Get your stories straight. You're telling me now that the other user had the code first, but then on PM you told me I had the code first.
No, I didn't. Read again. I might have given that impression, but I literally said "I had a guy fall through" inferring you were second.
And just to be completely transparent - the rest of the conversation. There's really no reason to go on any longer. I'm repeating what I said multiple times.
By fell through, I took that to mean that the transaction didn't occur, which is why you completed the transaction with me. Once our transaction was completed, you decided to go back and revisit the first transaction, which is where the problem is. You received my money first, but you gave the code out to two people.No, I didn't. Read again. I might have given that impression, but I literally said "I had a guy fall through" inferring you were second.
And just to be completely transparent - the rest of the conversation. There's really no reason to go on any longer. I'm repeating what I said multiple times.
Cloggerdude , pete_clarf can you weigh in on this? Also, zetsubou , wanna tell your side of the story?
It was a miscommunication at that point - we can keep talking but I don't see the point. I said, multiple times, I made a mistake. What do you want me to do now?
Not sure why you are giving battousai neutral feedback. It implies while the transaction got figured out, he did something wrong as well. Clearly you made quite a few mistakes.
OP
OP
From what you have both posted, it looks like battousai did absolutely nothing wrong during the transaction. I don't think you were trying to be malicious in any way, but the mistake of sending out the code to two people was completely on you. As such, I fail to see why battousai deserves Neutral feedback in this situation. Unless it's simply as a reaction to them leaving you Negative, in which case that's completely inappropriate. I know you have tried to explain yourself, but I'm really not seeing it.
That being said, I'm also not entirely sure that you deserve a full Negative, as you did at least immediately provide a refund. You made an incredibly dumb mistake, but it really doesn't appear to have been malicious. That's just my thoughts on it though.
I mean, it can be neutral feedback or no feedback. Positive or negative doesn't make sense on my end, really. It wasn't positive, even though that was my own fault no goods were even traded at the end. And it wasn't negative, because it was my fault. If I wanted to be malicious, I would have just said I have codes for the 10 people who PM'd me and ran. Just a bad decision on my part. Last thing I want to do is throw away the feedback I have because of a $10 code.
OP
OP
I completely understand not wanting to give Positive feedback here. Unfortunately, Neutral feedback has a fairly negative connotation, due to the small amount of individuals that have actually received that type of feedback. I kind of see how the naming is a bit...unfortunate now, but Neutral feedback is definitely not truly nuetral at the end of the day.
The best option here, at least in my opinion, would be to simply not leave any feedback at all.
The issue with this approach is that the feedback isn't for you.
The feedback is a way for the other party to give others their impression of working with you. While you receive the feedback, it doesn't mean you get to control it. There are many things you can do as a buyer or a seller to help ensure that the feedback you receive is positive, but there's no guarantee that it will end up that way. You made a mistake, and this is the result of that mistake.
The other party did not have a good experience, and as many have understood, didn't do anything wrong. Why isn't he allowed to leave feedback now because you backed out of the transaction, whether or not it was malicious? It was still a mistake on your part, and should just accept it as so.
Although, similar to the other feedback situation ongoing, if people decide to change it to neutral, I wouldn't be opposed to it neither, but I don't think it should just be complete forgotten with no feedback.
From the time I originally messaged him1246am to the time I paid (according to my PayPal email) was just under 2hour time span. He sent me the code at 116a, I used it before paying to make sure it was good, fucked around on the eshop then paid. My paypal email has a 230a timestamp. All times pst.
Positive seller feedback for steveovig
Easy to work with, shipped fast, and followed up via PM's quickly.
Easy to work with, shipped fast, and followed up via PM's quickly.
I haven't been too big on here lately (like past couple years), but would think this would be Neutral feedback for you. Nobody lost anything but time.
I would hope in the future though you double check to see if you got a refund before posting feedback.
Leaving battousai any feedback considering you are the cause of all the grief is bullshit. If you want to challenge his negative feedback then so be it. But retract this petty feedback.
Positive trader feedback for r3n4ud
Idk what it counts as? I had the listing if that categorizes it
Idk what it counts as? I had the listing if that categorizes it
I believe a trade is seller feedback for both. It's in the OP, I think.
By the recent standards of the community this should be neutral or no feeack.
