• Ever wanted an RSS feed of all your favorite gaming news sites? Go check out our new Gaming Headlines feed! Read more about it here.

Dali

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,184
No more Supernatural. No more 100. Gotta replace them with something. A space drama with a bunch of young hot people could be good.
 

StereoVSN

Member
Nov 1, 2017
13,620
Eastern US
I love Babylon 5. However, CW Babylon 5? That just brings up some major alarms. Oh well, lets see what happens. Maybe we'll get 1 good season out of it :).

No more Supernatural. No more 100. Gotta replace them with something. A space drama with a bunch of young hot people could be good.

This is what I am afraid of, and I liked Supernatural and first couple seasons of Flash / Supergirl / Smallville.
 

Dali

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,184
I love Babylon 5. However, CW Babylon 5? That just brings up some major alarms. Oh well, lets see what happens. Maybe we'll get 1 good season out of it :).



This is what I am afraid of, and I liked Supernatural and first couple seasons of Flash / Supergirl / Smallville.
Lol reading Smallville made me have a vision of every episode ending with the gang meeting up at the station's coffeeshop/bar recounting the day's events while a sappy pop song plays in the background.

Where do I sign up?
 

No Depth

Member
Oct 27, 2017
18,266
Can't they just remaster instead with improved CG, RTX, fps, and add 3D audio and widescreen??
 

WildGoose

Member
Oct 27, 2017
1,219
B5 was pure lightning in a bottle and there is no way they'll be able to replicate even half of what made it work without people like Furlan and Katsulas. Even if JMS is involved, and even if somehow some of the old cast come back. It's the last show in the world that needs a reboot.
 
Feb 16, 2018
2,680
more babylon 5?
tumblr_inline_n1exq7rbpQ1r041f6.gif


CW, our last best hope for a reboot
 

B.K.

Member
Oct 31, 2017
17,023
I signed up for HBO Max last weekend during the 50% off deal. I was going to start watching the original Babylon 5, but now, I might as well wait for the reboot. I don't know if I can watch such an old show with bad, 90s acting and worse than PS1 quality CG.
 

firehawk12

Member
Oct 25, 2017
24,162
What in the fuck.

I can't believe it... also being CW-fied is fucking terrifying.

But I guess we're just at that point where ANYTHING gets a remake now. lol
 

Calvinien

Banned
Jul 13, 2019
2,970
This is also going to be just generally low budget as shit isn't it?

I mean's it's babylon 5 so...yeah.

Anyways, who wants to bet on how exactly WB will torpedo this?

Air the eps out of order?
Rush the series to air before the cgi is done?
Replace JMS with joss whedon and have him antagonize literally the entire cast.?
Course, since this is B5 maybe they will dust off the old classic of mandating a bunch of changes at the last minute for the sole purpose of eating up the budget and making it economically unviable for any channel to run it while also deciding to no longer show it on the CW.
 

devSin

Member
Oct 27, 2017
6,194
Eh, at least on CW nobody has to watch it for them to keep making it.

Except for a Neil Gaiman guest episode, he wrote the script for every episode for the last four seasons of Babylon 5. I get the impression he's different in a lot of ways when it comes to his comic book writing, but he cranked out B5 scripts like there was no tomorrow.
JMS wrote Seasons 3 & 4 and the majority (but not entirety) of 5. Seasons 1 & 2 had a team of writers (or at least multiple guest writers).
 

Pluto

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,426
So many people complaining about the CW in this thread and I feel like I might be living in an alternate reality because from my perspective the CW has had a lot of great shows (and a lot of not so great shows but all networks have those).

All American
Supernatural
iZombie
The 100
Nikita
Jane the Virgin
Crazy Ex-Girlfriend
Superman & Lois
Black Lightning

And Babylon 5 originally aired on PTEN so it's weird to act like The CW is beneath Babylon 5.
 

Rodney McKay

Member
Oct 26, 2017
12,189
lol CW babylon 5

this is gonna last like a season
You joking? Even CW shows with terrible ratings get repeatedly renewed.

This isn't NBC or Fox where sci-fi never gets past a single season. Debris wasn't the best but I'd still have liked it to have gotten one more season at least, and you know that new "land of the lost" type show that's coming out won't last long.
 

19thCenturyFox

Prophet of Regret
Member
Oct 29, 2017
4,309
Please no sequel series. That's an even worse idea than a reboot.

EDIT:

So it's not a sequel but they are using the original cast in new roles? If so, cast Bruce Boxleitner as Morgan Clark please.
 
Last edited:

firehawk12

Member
Oct 25, 2017
24,162
What are the chances of:

a) a puppet episode
b) a musical episode
c) a parody of Star Trek episode

I want them all now.
 

Forsaken82

Member
Oct 27, 2017
4,924
The CW is actually less likely to cancel a show after one season than the other networks.

They also had The 100 which was actually a pretty good sci-fi show, it was a teen drama for about 4 or 5 episodes and then shit got serious. The network is probably the best place for a sci-fi show at the moment, if it makes it past season 1 (which is very likely) it is almost guaranteed at least 5 seasons.

And some of you should rewatch the original Babylon 5, it was ridiculously low budget, it will be very easy to have a new show look much better just because of how comparatively cheap good cgi has become. Take the new Battlestar Galactica for example and look at their space scenes, that show was also low budget but most people wouldn't think so looking at the finished product.


The CW had Supernatural which was centered around adults from the start and was ridiculously successful for them and the entire Arrowverse is very light on teenagers with many shows not featuring any teens at all. Jane the Virgin and Crazy Ex-Girlfriend were huge critical successes and also not centered on teens.

The CW also rebooted Roswell and in their version the characters are actually adults and not teenagers like in the original, them doing only teen shows is a myth.

Supernatural is debateable as when it first aired, Sam was technically still a teenager in college. FWIW I am a big fan of Supernatural, and stuck with it all 15 years, but it absolutely fit the typical CW Mold of teen heartthrobs in peril concept. As for Roswell, i never saw the reboot so I can't really speak to it. The point is, the CW has a demographic that the original concept of Babylon 5 doesn't quite fit. It'd be like saying "Star Trek coming to The CW!" except the actual show that the CW airs is Star Trek: Origin of Picard, a show that would focus on the early life/career of Picard. I'm sure the first 2 seasons would be Picard in Highschool or at best going through the Academy as a young 20 something.
 
Nov 27, 2020
4,246
Some of the original cast was involved in Battlestar Galactica reboot as well, doesn't mean they will be cast in their original roles though.
Going by the article in the OP, that's exactly what we'd be seeing here. That's pretty normal for a lot for CW reboots/reimaginings anyway.

That said, I could also imagine JMS sneakily doing a reboot/sequel where we have younger actors playing the characters in flashbacks, but keeping with the original's continuity, while having the main story take place in the future and driving the universe's story forward. I have to imagine that he's got a lot of stories that he never got to tell with Crusade and the rest of the attempted resurrections of the universe.
 

Quinton

Specialist at TheGamer / Reviewer at RPG Site
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,256
Midgar, With Love
LONDO: "In all my 25 years, I have never had an aide so inept as this one."
VIR: "I'm sorry, sir! It's just I... I... I'm 12."

MORDEN: "What do you want?"
LONDO: "The most popular Instagram in the known galaxy."

IVANOVA: "It's a Jewish prayer."
TALIA: "omg same LOL"

BYRON: wait no actually this one's already primed for CW
 

Lonewolf

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,900
Oregon
She says he wants them involved in some way, not necessarily their characters. They could play new characters in a reboot with their original parts recast. I mean, it wouldn't be reboot if it's a sequel.

Someone has to play the random aliens that make up The League of Non-Aligned Worlds, after all! ;p
 

Quinton

Specialist at TheGamer / Reviewer at RPG Site
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,256
Midgar, With Love
In all seriousness, this is like the absolute worst case scenario for me. I've always been in favor of a Babylon 5 reboot -- lightning in a bottle or not, I'd be interested in seeing if it can happen twice -- but I have a very, very low opinion of The CW. Its content doesn't mesh well with me at all.
 

19thCenturyFox

Prophet of Regret
Member
Oct 29, 2017
4,309
Babylon 5 is already older than the original Battlestar Galactica series was when it got rebooted.

Just in case you haven't felt old yet today.
 

Quinton

Specialist at TheGamer / Reviewer at RPG Site
Member
Oct 25, 2017
17,256
Midgar, With Love
Like. HBO was literally right there. Did JMS shop B5 around and get a dozen negatives? I always figured this IP isn't quite worth the dollars some folks believe, but good lord, this is bottom of the barrel.
 

Chance Hale

Member
Oct 26, 2017
11,830
Colorado
Riverdale actually has some pretty nice sets/costumes and Crazy Ex Girlfriend had a pretty sizable budget going by the musical numbers

Trust they're diversifying their lineup but we will see
 

Lonewolf

Attempted to circumvent ban with alt account
Banned
Oct 27, 2017
3,900
Oregon
Supernatural is debateable as when it first aired, Sam was technically still a teenager in college. FWIW I am a big fan of Supernatural, and stuck with it all 15 years, but it absolutely fit the typical CW Mold of teen heartthrobs in peril concept. As for Roswell, i never saw the reboot so I can't really speak to it. The point is, the CW has a demographic that the original concept of Babylon 5 doesn't quite fit. It'd be like saying "Star Trek coming to The CW!" except the actual show that the CW airs is Star Trek: Origin of Picard, a show that would focus on the early life/career of Picard. I'm sure the first 2 seasons would be Picard in Highschool or at best going through the Academy as a young 20 something.

That... wouldn't be that bad actually. They could do a reverse Tapestry episode as a series finale where Q tries to get Picard to not get involved in the fight with the Nausicaans that leads to him getting stabbed in the heart, only for it to backfire! They could flesh out the characters Cortan "Corey" Zweller and Marta "Marty" Batanides, two of Picards friends from his Academy days, as major characters.
 

Pluto

Member
Oct 25, 2017
6,426
Supernatural is debateable as when it first aired, Sam was technically still a teenager in college. FWIW I am a big fan of Supernatural, and stuck with it all 15 years, but it absolutely fit the typical CW Mold of teen heartthrobs in peril concept.
Sam was actually 22 when Supernatural started. But yes, they were young and probably appealed to a younger audience but the point is that the CW also had shows that didn't skew so young and I don't see why they would cast a bunch of teens or people in their early 20s for Babylon 5.
Superman & Lois features teenagers but the majority of the cast is in their 30s and 40s. Walker is similar, two teens in supporting roles but the rest of the cast is adults ranging from early 30s to 60s. And those are two of their more successful shows.


As for Roswell, i never saw the reboot so I can't really speak to it. The point is, the CW has a demographic that the original concept of Babylon 5 doesn't quite fit.
Claudia Christian was 28 when Babylon 5 started, Richard Biggs and Andrea Thompson 33, most of the others were 40+ but generally the age range isn't that different from some other CW shows.
And how does the original concept not fit the CW demographic? They've been doing genre shows for years now and definitely have an audience for them, Babylon 5 had action, mystery, some comic relief, love stories etc., I can see it working well for them.
And if they must have some younger characters Vir and Lennier could easily be aged down to early 20s without changing their characters, they both were portrayed as young and inexperienced compared to their respective ambassadors (even if Bill Mumy was actually older than Mira Furlan).


LONDO: "In all my 25 years, I have never had an aide so inept as this one."
VIR: "I'm sorry, sir! It's just I... I... I'm 12."

MORDEN: "What do you want?"
LONDO: "The most popular Instagram in the known galaxy."

IVANOVA: "It's a Jewish prayer."
TALIA: "omg same LOL"

BYRON: wait no actually this one's already primed for CW
When was the last time you actually watched anything on the CW? Because that sounds more like a bad parody of what people expect from the CW not what most of their content is actually like.
 

Xero grimlock

Member
Dec 1, 2017
2,944
I signed up for HBO Max last weekend during the 50% off deal. I was going to start watching the original Babylon 5, but now, I might as well wait for the reboot. I don't know if I can watch such an old show with bad, 90s acting and worse than PS1 quality CG.
You will be missing out on an incredible show, but if too old for you to handle then it's whatever.
 

Silence

Member
Oct 27, 2017
663
United States
I think there are some seriously premature reactions here. I love the original B5, it's my all time favorite show. I would like there to be more of it, and if a reboot is the way JMS makes that happen, then it's great freaking news.

Sure, I'd love to see an expansion of the story, but obviously that's not what is on the table. WB owns the TV rights to B5, so where else would it go but CW?

I hope this is good, if it's not, whatever, that takes NOTHING away from the original. This could be the way to get B5 into the main stream in a way it hasn't been for decades, and that is good news to me.

With Claudia saying original cast are involved in some way, there are tons of ways this could go that could be genuinely exciting. JMS gave us B5, and I don't know anyone else I would trust more to bring it back respectfully.
 

gblues

Member
Oct 25, 2017
2,482
Tigard, OR
To be true to the original series, all VFX shots will be rendered in real time using a Pentium 4 and a dusty GTX 750ti.

Honestly, I'm not worried about it being a CW show. The thing that I'm looking forward to the least is the zoomers who are going to watch this show as their first exposure to Babylon 5 and accuse JMS of ripping off Mass Effect and/or re-igniting the DS9-vs-B5 fanbase wars of the late 90s.
 
Oct 25, 2017
2,944
Let's fucking do this. Totally down, up to and including the CW portion. The 100 was a lot better than a lot of people realize, B5 deserves another shot at making it, and CW will keep shit around for forever.

This lets it keep a little of the scrappy underdog spirit that powered the original; I'd have anxiety about cancellation constantly if they gave it a full on HBO budget.